4 ms·
Actually, if someone promises you a million dollars verbally, then in common law you can rely on that promise (subject to many caveats and details, IANAL etc).
by jacques_chester 16y ago
Actually, if someone promises you a million dollars verbally, then in common law you can rely on that promise (subject to many caveats and details, IANAL etc). In fact you might be able to rely on it in several ways -- contract law, estoppel law etc.
To avoid he-said/she-said, many business contracts include a written "no-verbals clause", saying in essence that the contract can't be amended except in writing.
This is necessary because contractual relationships do not need to be written. The elements which the law pattern matches to say "this is a contract" do not require "must be written down somewhere" (though again, there are exceptions - for example many jurisdictions have legislation requiring property contracts to be in writing). For example, when you buy a stick of gum, you have negotiated, agreed to and executed a contract with an agent of the seller (the clerk). Contracts are largely invisible in every day life, but they exist. The decision to write them down is a risk-management exercise, where contract parties realise that the cost of settling disputes about verbal disputes is higher than the cost of signing a written contract.
In this case the common sense has been to rule that an IM message was "writing", thus it was not treated by the no-verbals clause, thus it successfully amended the original contract.
Now currently these modification clauses are blacklisting based. You name what you won't count as modifying the contract. If it hasn't happened already, a smart lawyer will look for a whitelisting approach, where you list what will count in future. So instead of "no verbal, no IM, no twitter, no currently-unforeseen-service-X", you'll get "on paper only".
Again, I am not a lawyer, this is not legal advice etc etc.