3 ms·
the core of his argument: that your insight about the relation between Hackers and Painters is superficial, and where it applies at all, it's built on knowledge
by pg 18y ago
the core of his argument: that your insight about the relation between Hackers and Painters is superficial, and where it applies at all, it's built on knowledge of painting that is itself superficial.
Can you give an example where you feel he has successfully refuted something specific I said about painting?
- tptacek 18y agoSure. I've taken his thesis and applied it, substituting "pastry chef" for "painter" into the text of each of the topic sentences in the lead graf of each section of your essay. The essay continues to work. Your critic's point seems valid. You learn to bake mostly by doing it. Ditto for hacking. Because pastry chefs leave a trail of work behind them, you can watch them learn by doing. For a pastry chef, a cookbook is a reference library of techniques. Another example we can take from pastry is the way that dishes are created by gradual refinement. New dishes usually begin with a sketch. In hacking, like pastry, work comes in cycles. Sometimes you get excited about some new project and you want to work sixteen hours a day on it. Other times nothing seems interesting. A lot of the great cooking of the past is the work of multiple hands, though there may only be one name on the wall of the restaurant. Like pastry, most software is intended for a human audience.
- pg 18y agoThat's not a refutation. Find something specific I said about painting that he has shown to be false, not merely also true of some other field. For example, pick one of the list of statements I made about painting that he quotes in that list in the middle, and explain how you feel he has refuted it. Or any other statement about painting he quotes.
- tptacek 18y agoYour argument was that painting has an interesting connection to hacking. "No it doesn't," your critic argues, "because in fact you can make the same argument about many other professions --- for an absurd example, take pastry chefs". Unless we're secretly on Usenet, he's refuted your argument. He used evidence to deny the premise of your essay. Draw his argument out further, and you can make the same statements about law, insurance, and surgery. For instance, "because constitutional lawyers leave a trail of work behind them, you can watch them learn by doing." Or, "a lot of the great innovations in corporate reinsurance are the work of multiple hands, though there may only be only a few names in the list of partners at the firm". Also: it took time to re-read your essay, read his essay, jog my memory about your book, and write that response. I'm not sure I feel like your response to me dignified that work. Can you respond this time without redefining the word "refute" to suit your argument?
- pg 18y agoThe challenge I gave you was to find any specific statement I made about painting that he has shown to be false. It's a disingenous trick to claim that the thesis of the essay is implicitly a statement about painting. Not that he has even refuted that. But put that point aside for the time being, and let's return to my original challenge, which I hope is clear now. Find one specific sentence or series of sentences I wrote about painting that he has shown to be false. If my understanding of painting is "superficial," I should have made lots of mistakes, right? So let's have one.
- tptacek 18y agoSorry, Paul. I read your essay and his as essays, not as series of independent sentences to be reviewed like lines of C in a group code review. I therefore reject the premise that I am somehow obligated to find an individual statement in it that is provably false. Next, since you wrote the essay and not me, you're clearly in a position to dictate what the essay "is about". Clearly, both me and your critic read it as being "about" the connection between hackers and painters. I muster as evidence the facts that: * The essay was titled "Hackers and Painters" * The essay said there was an interesting connection between hackers and painters in the topic sentence of the lead graf. * Of the 89 grafs in the essay, 26 have as their topic the connection between programming and painting. * Of the 17 sections in the essay, 10 of them have as their thesis statement either a specific connection between programming and painting, or an explanation of why that connection is important. If you want to argue that your essay is "about" something other than painting, there's not much I can about that other than to complain about unfairness. I'd rather not. As to whether your understanding of painting is superficial, I certainly wouldn't know. But your critic repeatedly and explicitly says it is, again with evidence. Which of his arguments ring false to you? You might start with his footnotes.
- pg 18y agoI've seen quite a lot of evasions when I asked people to get specific, but this is definitely the longest. I didn't ask you to find a passage that's provably false, just any specific statement I made that you feel he's refuted. It's a red herring to suggest that simply because I ask you for evidence, I'm somehow claiming that essays work like math. You're not of course obligated to provide evidence, when asked for it, but most people on forums do so voluntarily in order to preserve their credibility.