3 ms·
The term “capitalist” was not coined by critics of capitalism. For example, David Ricardo used the term decades before Marx. Criticizing capitalism by linking i
by rayiner 6y ago
The term “capitalist” was not coined by critics of capitalism. For example, David Ricardo used the term decades before Marx. Criticizing capitalism by linking it to slavery was pioneered by Marx, and accepting that point of view is Marxist rhetoric.
It is, of course, logically invalid to claim that because slavery was practiced in countries that happened to be capitalist, that slavery is capitalist. By that logic, slavery is Christian and Islamic too—even more so. I’m not interested in debating Marx’s criticisms of capitalism: the fact that we’re even having this conversation proves my original concern—the resurgence of Marxism in America. I will point out that, in contemporary usage “capitalism” assumes a free market, which is incompatible with slavery both in theory and in practice. (America got richer after it abandoned slavery, which is what free market theories of economics would predict.) Trying to link what people understand capitalism to be today, to the proto-capitalism practiced in the American south, is layering specious argument upon specious argument.
- jahaja 6y agoAre you honestly going to try to weasel your way out of this by laser-focusing on the semantic and etymological differences between capitalist and Capitalism which so far in the discussion have been used inter-changeably? > accepting that point of view is Marxist rhetoric. So if one agrees with Marx on a single point one is spouting Marxist rhetoric just because he wrote about it first? You just can't surgically remove selective things from Capitalism to get some wholesome version of it today. The patient would bleed out. I'm sorry, but you might be the most dishonest user of HN, a constant barrage of cherry-picking, diversions, omissions etc, woven into a, albeit articulate, good news narrative about Capitalism, the US, and conservatism.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The term “capitalist” was not coined by critics of capitalism The term “capitalist” for people who control capital was not, the term “capitalism” for a politicoeconomic system (from which comes “capitalist” in its other sense of an advocate/defender of that system, or, as an adjective, pertaining to that systemas, opposed to labelling a particular economic class) was. > It is, of course, logically invalid to claim that because slavery was practiced in countries that happened to be capitalist, that slavery is capitalist. It would.be, but that's not the argument. Early modern chattel slavery evolved alongside capitalism, was imposed exclusively by capitalist powers, and reflects the apotheosis of the capitalist commodification of labor from the mutualism of feudal relations, even beyond wage-labor, and the evolution beyond capitalism in the direction, if not by the means, advocated by critics like Marx that led to the modern mixed economy displacing the system for which “capitalism” was coined began with abolition of slavery. Early modern chattel slavery (not slavery more generally, such as feudal or ancient patriarchal slavery, including serfdom) was a distinctly and exclusively capitalist institution.