5 ms·
Title is misleading. To me, the headline "AIDS vaccine in final testing" implies that they are undergoing their final testing to verify that it does indeed prev
by scott_s 16y ago
Title is misleading. To me, the headline "AIDS vaccine in final testing" implies that they are undergoing their final testing to verify that it does indeed prevent people from contracting HIV. That is not what it means. Rather, it means that they are in the final rounds to verify that the vaccine is safe, before they start human trials.
A more accurate title, to my ears, would be "HIV vaccine almost ready for human trials."
- sabat 16y agoYou're correct about what stage they're at, but this is still very exciting news.
- eli 16y agoor even, "New HIV vaccines almost ready for human trials" since, according to wikipedia, there have been at least 13 previous phase 1 trials. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HIV_vaccine#Phase_I http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HIV_vaccine#Phase_I
- reason 16y agoYes, you're correct. There are 3 major phases in clinically testing a drug's safety and efficacy before it's brought to market, and it seems like they're close to starting the first one. For all those interested in the 3 phases, here they are: Phase 1: Small number of healthy volunteers to assess drug safety, toxicity, and pharmacokinetics. Phase 2: Small number of patients with the disease of interest to test drug efficacy. Phase 3: Large number of patients with the disease of interest to test effects of new treatment in comparison to those of existing treatments. This is where you see double-blind studies, etc. Personally, this isn't terribly noteworthy. They've merely devised a new theory that's shown to be effective using animal models, and are still quite a ways away from seeing if similar results will occur with human testing. Of course, I do hope they see good results.
- patrickaljord 16y ago> Phase 2: Small number of patients with the disease of interest to test drug efficacy. > Phase 3: Large number of patients with the disease of interest to test effects of new treatment in comparison to those of existing treatments. I'm not sure phase 2 and 3 make sense for a vaccine though. Vaccines are only useful for healthy people. I guess the testing is done on healthy animals which are then transmitted the HIV virus, unless some people would accept to go through that kind of testing, not very likely but I'm no specialist so I may be wrong.
- evgen 16y agoFor vaccines you test against a population and compare disease rates between the people who received the vaccine and those that did not. In situations like this I would guess that they will select a high-risk group and then compare infection rates over time between the two groups to see if the vaccine has any effect.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jessriedel 16y agoAs explained elsewhere, you give the vaccine and a placebo to an at-risk. Than you follow up X years later to check infection rates. Everything's double blind, so there's nothing statistically different about the two populations other than the vaccine vs. placebo. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2389732 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2389732
- electromagnetic 16y agoSuper-sucks to be in the placebo group on this one if the vaccine really works. It reminds me of a study done in IIRC South Africa (although it's been a year or more since I heard of this so it could be anywhere in Africa really) where they circumcised a group of males to see the effect on HIV contraction and it was so great (due to HIV's severely limited lifetime outside the body compared to over viruses and bacteria's) that they ended up circumcising the control group. Hopefully if this study goes well then they'll do the same. I'd sense a massive lawsuit if scientists caught major wind of a guaranteed vaccine and sat on it for the sake of evidence for 5 years and let X-many people get HIV.
- Vivtek 16y agoI'd sense a massive lawsuit if scientists caught major wind of a guaranteed vaccine and sat on it That's why you do this phase in poor countries. Duh. For instance, contraceptives were widely tested in Puerto Rico in the 50's before being put on the national market in the 60's. They weren't initially sold in Puerto Rico, though, because there wasn't enough money in it yet. [Caveat: I don't know this from personal experience - it's common knowledge in Puerto Rico, but then it's common knowledge here in Indiana that Barack Obama is a foreign-born Muslim, so ... take it all with a grain of salt.]