3 ms·
If you submit something for peer review, by definition it has to go to a wider audience, it has to go to people who may share it with others, it has to leave th
by LatteLazy 6y ago
If you submit something for peer review, by definition it has to go to a wider audience, it has to go to people who may share it with others, it has to leave the companies control etc. You generally don't even get to know who it goes to, let alone force NDAs on them. At that point you cannot hope to keep it private. So what you're doing is releasing price-sensitive information, but only to a select few (reviewers, their teams, journal admin staff, printers etc). That's unfair as they may well trade on the information defrauding others.
So you have to release it to everyone to be fair.
But you put a disclaimer on it to say its "not peer reviewed, preliminary etc".
Then if an expert wants to trade on it, they can and they're not left out just for not being part of the peer review circuit. And if an idiot doesn't read the disclaimer, that's his problem.
I agree that we get 1000s of dumb articles from hacks based on a non-peer-reviewed, "we're only releasing this statement because we're required to" data. But the issue there is journalists being lazy, editors refusing to do their jobs and readers rewarding them IMHO, not too much transparency. At least that's what I thought before people started drinking pool cleaner...