2 ms·
> Have you honestly never seen a review of a closed source program? Never seen anyone write about their likes or dislikes? Never seen any shareware/try before y
by lmm 6y ago
> Have you honestly never seen a review of a closed source program? Never seen anyone write about their likes or dislikes? Never seen any shareware/try before you buy/free tier software? Never seen anyone use some, decide it was bad, and change to another vendor? Never seen someone try the free version of SQL server or comment about their experiences with IIS or review a new release of Windows?
For enterprise software? Pretty much no. You don't tend to get shareware-style free trials, the more common model is a fully functional (and sometimes even open source) free version and then a paid version with additional features. Companies do switch vendors but it's hard to impossible to connect that with the actual user experience. You see case studies but usually published by the vendor themselves; a neutral reviewer doing comparisons is virtually unheard of. And it's pretty common for the licenses to forbid benchmarking or reviews (Oracle famously does).
When you're talking about software that only makes sense on the scale of a multi-machine network, who's going to go to the trouble of reviewing it? My experience is that hobbyists sometimes will, but only for the open-source stuff. Back when I worked for a Fortune 500 client we did do full-scale evaluations of proprietary systems, but they were always internal-only. If you're big enough to have your own evaluation department then sure, knock yourself out (this company was also big enough to do things like use their own internal programming language). But for a medium-sized company it's just too risky IME.