10 ms·
The Many Methods of Communicating with Submarines
- supernova87a 6y agoI love reading about stuff like this! I had 2 questions perpetually on my mind: 1) The article doesn't go into physical sonic wave communication, like ultrasonic I suppose. Did that ever have applications for submarine comms? 2) I always wonder whether like in the movies, submarines actually have or ever use the audible ping. Of course, it gives away one's position instantly, but does such a ping capability even exist still, on modern submarines?
- kevinskii 6y agoI was a sonar tech on a nuclear submarine 20 years ago. I don't recall hearing about any ultrasonic applications. As for the "audible ping": Yes, such a capability exists, and it is very much like the movies. It is rarely used for the reason you mentioned.
- drtillberg 6y agoRe: #2, that is active sonar, which is for useful for locating objects that are silent, e.g., rocks.[1] It also is very loud and disruptive for whales and dolphins.[2] [1] https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/sonar.html https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/sonar.html [2] https://skeptoid.com/episodes/4236 https://skeptoid.com/episodes/4236
- supernova87a 6y agoAh of course, the issue several years ago when the Navy's testing was causing whale / dolphin strandings...
- aoki 6y ago1) Yes, it’s nicknamed “Gertrude”. 2) Yes, every tactical platform that hunts subs has an active sonar capability of some kind. (Hull mounted, towed, dipping, sonobuoys, ...) When the ambient noise floor exceeds the target sub’s noise, you need that option.
- throw0101a 6y agoWhat, nothing about NATO's JANUS? > JANUS performance has so far been evaluated by many collaborating partners at centre frequencies from 900 Hz - 60 kHz and over distances up to 28 kilometers in waters all over the world. > JANUS packet and bit error rates have been computed as functions of the signal to the noise ratio (SNR) and time spread over periods extending from hours to months. Signal correlation times have been computed and long-term experiments by CMRE(external link) in 2008 and 2009 have helped quantify robustness during variable environmental conditions. * http://www.januswiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=About+Janus http://www.januswiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=About+Janus Toolkits available under GPLv3. * https://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/infrastructure/a27247/nato-janus-underwater-communication/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/infrastructure/a... * https://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/telecom/wireless/nato-develops-first-standardized-acoustic-signal-for-underwater-communications https://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/telecom/wireless/nato-de... * https://robohub.org/janus-creates-a-new-era-for-digital-underwater-communications/ https://robohub.org/janus-creates-a-new-era-for-digital-unde...
- notthetup 6y agoJANUS looks great on paper, but is pretty restrictive for doing anything useful in real life. At the standard frequency bands they've chosen (9440-13600 Hz), with the type of coding scheme they use FH-BFSK, the bandwidth is too limited (4KHz -> ) to do anything except service discovery. Having said that, I agree, it should have been mentioned.
- throw0101a 6y ago> JANUS looks great on paper, but is pretty restrictive for doing anything useful in real life. Were they going for reliability rather than bandwidth? Are there any alternative 'underwater modem/codec' standards?
- FabHK 6y ago> “It sometimes seems hard to believe that we humans have managed to explore so little of what we have so much of: the seas.” Apparently fewer people have been to the bottom of the Mariana trench (between 11 and 12,732 km away from you) than to the moon (about 400,000 km away from you).
- RandomBacon 6y agoVisiting the bottom of the Mariana Tench might be feasible for some people here. Apparently there are three slots available on a first-come-first-serve basis, for $750,000. https://www.cnn.com/travel/article/marianas-trench-challenger-deep-dive/index.html https://www.cnn.com/travel/article/marianas-trench-challenge... Climbing Everest used to be a bucket list item for me, but not anymore after I hear how bad it's gotten over the years. Going into space seems more feasible for me than the trench, only $250,000.
- FabHK 6y agoYeah, Mt Everest... nobody goes there anymore, it’s too crowded ;-) I happened to be in Guam in 2012 and in some dodgy dive bar (...) ran into the crew that took James Cameron down to Challenger Deep, only the second manned descent ever. Didn’t believe them a word until I saw my couch surfing host dancing with Cameron.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Yeah, Mt Everest... nobody goes there anymore, it’s too crowded ;-) Mt. Everest is the kind of place where that could be literally true (though I don't think it is, yet), if you count corpses as part the crowding...
- obmelvin 6y agoWhile I do feel like it is still an appropriate joke to make in the sense that it sounds ridiculous to say you aren't interested in Mt Everest because its too crowded, sadly it seems we have already reached that point in time - https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2019/05/24/mount-everest-has-gotten-so-crowded-that-climbers-are-perishing-traffic-jams/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2019/05/24/mount-everes...
- codezero 6y agoI remember researching this in 2008 and I thought satellite based lasers were already in common usage (sending signal to specific known surface location and also receiving from that location using the surface of the ocean as the medium that the sub and satellite read. This was a while ago so no links maybe I’m misremembering.
- dylan604 6y agothey do this with directional encrypted radio. what would be the advantage of doing it with a laser other than 'friggin' laser'?
- kdeldycke 6y agoAlso learned about submarine to satellite direct communications with lasers in a 33c3 video at: https://youtu.be/P4Qk88IpND0?t=32m8s https://youtu.be/P4Qk88IpND0?t=32m8s Source: https://twitter.com/kdeldycke/status/830035138805428224 https://twitter.com/kdeldycke/status/830035138805428224
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SaberTail 6y agoMy favorite attempt to get the Department of Defense to pay for physics research is a paper that suggests building a muon storage ring and using that to generate a beam of neutrinos to communicate with submarines[1]. The physical principals are pretty sound. We do already generate neutrino beams, like at Fermilab[2]. And we do have the ability to detect neutrinos in water, optically as ANTARES[3] does, or acoustically, as SAUND[4] demonstrated. There are some serious engineering challenges to building a muon storage ring, which is why we don't have any. If we could build them, we could build a muon collider. Muon colliders would be great. Muons are elementary particles, and don't have all the garbage inside that a proton does, and so you'd get very clean signals out of such a collider, unlike the LHC. And since muons are much heavier than electrons, it's easier to get them to very high energies without losing a lot of power to synchrotron radiation. [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/0909.4554 https://arxiv.org/abs/0909.4554 [2] https://www.fnal.gov/pub/science/particle-physics/experiments/neutrinos.html https://www.fnal.gov/pub/science/particle-physics/experiment... [3] https://antares.in2p3.fr/Overview/index.html https://antares.in2p3.fr/Overview/index.html [4] http://saund.stanford.edu/saund1/ http://saund.stanford.edu/saund1/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Enginerrrd 6y agoI've often wondered about the feasbility of a private firm doing something similar to dominate the HFT scene by getting a massive lead on information from the opposite end of the globe.
- SpaceRaccoon 6y agoThey would dominate indeed, but potentially at the detriment of Neutrino research detector sensitivity world-wide.
- schoen 6y ago
- larrik 6y ago> The 228,000 ocean-dwelling species that we know about represents about ten percent of the estimated total aquatic species. I don't buy it. The idea that the deep ocean is full of all this life we haven't plundered yet seems like a fantasy.
- nickff 6y agoThey usually make these types of estimates by looking at the rate of new species discovery, and assuming it will asymptotically approach zero.
- gerdesj 6y agoDo you have any idea just how vast the seas are? Think about it for a while. Consider that we mostly bob about on top and that is much bigger area compared to dry land. Now allow that it keeps on moving and drops away to up to 11 Km deep. Our senses are nearly useless in this alien world. 10% is just an educated guess and may be woefully low.
- waste_monk 6y ago>The idea that the deep ocean is full of all this life we haven't plundered yet seems like a fantasy. It's quite simple, they count the total number of species in the ocean and then use the number of species we know about to work out the percentage.
- Sharlin 6y ago"Species" includes arthropods, other invertebrates, and everything else all the way down to single-cellular organisms. And there is an incredible abundance of variety among those forms of life. I doubt we have even catalogued 10% of all species of beetles, never mind of all oceanic life.
- akira2501 6y agoThe USSR used buoys extensively during the cold war. Here's a former naval officer describing the sonar based system: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eb6e_-HvBzw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eb6e_-HvBzw
- audiometry 6y agoI recently stumbled on this channel. It’s amazing to watch him “twitch stream” analyzing an underwater recording to pull out all sorts of interesting insights while only using a consumer, general purpose audio software.
- walrus01 6y agoYou can do some pretty effective low bitrate critical satcom stuff with a buoy and molniya orbit satellites. The Russian military has been launching molniya orbit narrowband comms satellites periodically for the past 45 years. They're used for ground, air and naval C4I purposes. With the long satellite dwell time over high latitude and Arctic regions, a submarine in the arctic ocean could surface a buoy that has a radome in its top, containing a small yagi-uda antenna with a fat oval gain pattern aimed straight up at the sky.
- sparker72678 6y agoIf you like this kind of stuff checkout "Blind Man's Bluff: The Untold Story Of American Submarine Espionage" There are so many fascinating details about submarine operations that are now unclassified (and makes you guess about what things are like that are still hidden). From communications to the underground listening stations to attempting (and succeeding) in wire-tapping soviet communication cables, to attempting to lift a wrecked foreign submarine right off the ocean floor. It's an amazing read and very well written.
- dfsegoat 6y agoThe audiobook has some nice extra commentary as well. That book blew the cover off missions that hadn’t been known to the public at all, so it was a bit controversial at release - the commentary touches on all that. Red November and The Taking of K129 are also great reads along these lines.
- sparker72678 6y agoI loved the audiobook, but somehow I missed the controversy part. Thanks for the recommendations!
- KineticLensman 6y agoI think you mean 'The hunt for Red October'
- b06tmm 6y agoThanks! I just downloaded the Kindle book.
- fortran77 6y agoI worked on the Eaton AIL CVLF radio receiver, which was the one of the first digital radio receivers done in the late 1980s. Because the frequencies used to communicate with subs were around 19 kHz, the CPUs of the time were just fast enough to do the signal processing. We used the Fairchild 9445 which was essentially a Data General "Nova 4" on a chip. This receiver was used to receive launch commands. It received teletype data that was printed on a Model 29 Teletype. The encryption keys and the key generator used on this project were compromised by the Walkers, a family of spies (See https://news.usni.org/2014/09/02/john-walker-spy-ring-u-s-navys-biggest-betrayal https://news.usni.org/2014/09/02/john-walker-spy-ring-u-s-na... ) The Submarines dragged a wire antenna that was used to receive the VLF radio signals, that were transmitted from several megawatt sites within the US and beyond.
- elchief 6y agoI recall an X-Files episode where a woman was affected by the transmission of a ULF or ELF antenna and it was making her crazy. Was a fun episode Here it is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drive_(The_X-Files) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drive_(The_X-Files)
- gorgoiler 6y agoAh yes: the other Vince Gilligan TV show starring Bryan Cranston.
- hchz 6y agoYou can actually hear some forms of Gertrude through the hull! I slept with my head right near the hull, and when we did a certain kind of op where it was in use, you could faintly hear what sounded like a home modem.
- kayfox 6y agoYou can hear it in the movie The Abyss as well, since Cameron is a stickler for accuracy.
- hchz 6y agoI was disappointed with how much this missed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fleet_Satellite_Communications_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fleet_Satellite_Communications... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UFO_(satellite) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UFO_(satellite) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milstar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milstar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Broadcast_Service https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_Broadcast_Service https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_Satellite_Communications_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_Satellite_Communicatio... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Extremely_High_Frequency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Extremely_High_Freque... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_Essential_Emergency_Communications_Network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_Essential_Emergency_Co... The interesting aspects of how USN submarines access these systems doesn't appear to be openly available.
- 082349872349872 6y agoTo some degree one can guess some parameters by reverse engineering the list of dual-use technologies: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23548220 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23548220 (with my experiences, I see far more submarine detection than communication, but those differently geeky may have better luck.)
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> FLTSATCOM 7 and FLTSATCOM 8 have been used for repeating UHF Satcom transmissions by unauthorized radio users particularly in Brazil, including criminals, illegal loggers, truckers and individuals located in remote areas. I wonder how much disruption they're causing...
- peter_d_sherman 6y ago>"While the high frequency (HF: 3 MHz to 30 MHz) and low frequency (LF: 30 kHz to 300 kHz) bands are perfectly capable of reaching across the globe thanks to ionospheric refraction, the high conductivity of seawater rapidly attenuates signals in these bands. Dialing down the spectrum a bit, the very low frequency (VLF: 3 kHz to 30 kHz) band starts to exhibit decent penetration of seawater, down to a depth of perhaps 20 meters." [...] >"Going even further down the spectrum, signals in the extremely low frequency (ELF: 3 Hz to 30 Hz) band are capable of penetrating 120 meters of seawater" Submarines aside, this is tremendously interesting how specific mediums (in this case, salt water) either act as transducers or attenuators for different radio frequencies. Now, when a radio frequency is influenced by some form of matter (in this case, salt water, and at higher frequencies, attenuation), it might be because the matter and the radio frequency are somehow related. In other words, perhaps future scientists will discover that the molecules of water are resonating at a frequency which is a much higher harmonic than the radio waves that they block. And/or perhaps their frequency is somehow related to the much lower frequency radio waves that they conduct. See, it's sort of like any attenuator can act as a conductor (or vice versa), but the frequency or set of frequencies used makes the determination as to whether the medium in question is going to attenuate or conduct... Compare this concept to resistors in electronics. They resist standard DC... but what about AC at a certain frequency, or pulsed DC at a certain frequency? The higher the frequency (to a certain point when space becomes conductive and thus dissipative with respect to the circuit), the more a resistor should become a conductor... Also, observation: The reason why distance is lost (in seawater, but also other mediums) when higher frequencies are used, is typically because power is converted into frequency, which then, in the case of a standard radio wave, expands into space as a sphere, that is, it's a inverse-square-law power loss over space. Compare radio waves to lasers; lasers do not lose power in accord with the inverse-square-law over space...
- bertjk 6y ago>They resist standard DC... but what about AC at a certain frequency, or pulsed DC at a certain frequency? Um.. yes. This is actually exactly how you model coupling capacitors when analyzing circuits. You use them to connect two nodes. Apply DC and no current flows through once the capacitor is charged. Apply AC and the signal is transmitted to the other side. The strength of the transmitted signal is dependent on frequency and of course whatever else you have connected to the circuit.
- walrus01 6y agoI just did a Ctrl-f on this comments page, and on the article for "iridium", and I'm surprised nobody has mentioned the disposable/expendable iridium buoys yet. They absolutely exist and come in several varieties. These are not as big a secret as they were 15 years ago. The USN was the first user of such things, but other NATO countries have also purchased and deployed them, or developed their own models.