5 ms·
> when we find ourselves in a situation where 20% of the workforce is suddenly unemployed due to a shutdown of economic output, the government can spend to help
by pdonis 6y ago
> when we find ourselves in a situation where 20% of the workforce is suddenly unemployed due to a shutdown of economic output, the government can spend to help stabilise aggregate incomes without risking inflation
The root problem with printing money is not inflation, it's wealth transfer. Printing money, whether it leads to inflation (increase in average price level--note that this usage of the term "inflation" is itself a product of Keynes, its older and more proper use was "increase in the quantity of money") or not, always means a transfer of wealth from whoever does not get some of the printed money to whoever does. In other words, it is a transfer of buying power.
In the current situation, where the transfer is spread widely across everyone and has the explicit effect of compensating people for loss of income due to no fault of their own, it is hard to argue that the transfer is a bad thing, and it won't cause much economic distortion or misallocation of resources because the printed money is going to be spent on much the same things as the lost income would have been spent on anyway. So the buying power is being used for much the same things as it was before.
However, in most cases of printing money, the transfer is very different. The way the US government has been doing it basically since the Federal Reserve existed, it is a transfer from everyone who is not a financial institution, to financial institutions. This causes serious economic distortion and misallocation of resources, because it significantly changes what the buying power is used for. That is why, for example, we have McMansions galore in the US and newly constructed office space sitting empty for years in many metro areas, while we also have many ordinary citizens having trouble making ends meet, crumbling infrastructure, and underfunded basic services: because printing money and giving it to financial institutions redirects buying power to housing purchased with mortgages and commercial construction funded with loans, instead of what the people whose buying power has been transferred away would have spent it on.
- perl4ever 6y ago>it is a transfer from everyone who is not a financial institution, to financial institutions I don't understand what this means. Aren't the victims you are imagining the hypothetical people who have large amounts of money in checking, savings, or literally under their mattress? And maybe this is ignorant, but I really didn't think that was a significant segment of the population. I've read comments like yours a million times before, so I know your take isn't unique or novel, I just have never understood it at all. I guess I can interpret you as talking about say inflation in the 1970s, but at this point that seems like ancient history and moot.
- pdonis 6y ago> I don't understand what this means Suppose you have ten people and the money supply is a hundred dollars, of which each person has ten. And then suppose you print ten more dollars and give them all to person #10, so that person now has 20 dollars. That is equivalent, economically, to keeping the money supply the same but taking 91 cents from each of the other 9 people and giving it to person #10: in both cases, person #10 now has 2/11 of the total money supply, and persons #1 through #9 each have 1/11. And that means their respective fractions of the total buying power have changed the same way, since the buying power of money is the fraction of the total money supply that that money is equal to. So person #10 can now buy more of the things he wants, and everyone else can buy less. In the case of the Federal Reserve printing money under normal circumstances, person #10 is financial institutions and persons #1 through #9 are everybody else. > Aren't the victims you are imagining the hypothetical people who have large amounts of money in checking, savings, or literally under their mattress? The "victims" are everybody who isn't getting some of the printed money. The fact that they already have other money doesn't change the fact that they lose buying power. Nor does it matter where their other money is stored. It could even be in assets like a 401k; as long as the assets are denominated in money (your 401k balance is in dollars), the buying power they represent is affected. > I really didn't think that was a significant segment of the population. Everybody who doesn't get new money the Federal Reserve prints under normal circumstances is almost all of the population.
- perl4ever 6y ago>as long as the assets are denominated in money (your 401k balance is in dollars) This seems to me like saying that if the size of an inch shrinks, things measured in inches will too. I mean, for the sake of argument, maybe they will shrink and maybe they won't, but the choice of inches vs. cm can't affect that; it's extrinsic. This sounds very much like something I've read for decades, that it matters greatly if oil is denominated in dollars, and it's made no sense to me in all that time. >Everybody who doesn't get new money the Federal Reserve prints under normal circumstances is almost all of the population People complain about stagnating real wages, but I'm unaware of exponentially declining real wages, let alone the same happening to investments, as you mention, like 401(k)s. I don't see how the details matter; if there was significant wealth transfer from almost everybody, then it would be obvious. I think you are saying that somehow, in emotional terms, the banks are a vampiric drain on the economy. But how are they doing that? If they somehow make money vanish, then doesn't that mean it isn't circulating and causing buying power and inflation? In which case how can it matter? If all the excess money is being hoarded by a tiny number of people who are not spending it, isn't that protecting us from the ravages of inflation? If I have a trillion dollar coin, regardless of where I got it, it's nothing, unless someone takes it seriously when I say "please make me 10 aircraft carriers". The idea that financial institutions possess all wealth is so weird I'm not sure I can believe anyone believes it. You can look up how much they are worth, would you say that the published figures are misleading, or do you think that regular public financial companies and banks are vastly outweighed by other entities?