4 ms·
Does anyone know what could be a specific reason leading to this change? I mean, deeper than "no single market", what would prevent Amazon from running the same
by viraptor 6y ago
Does anyone know what could be a specific reason leading to this change? I mean, deeper than "no single market", what would prevent Amazon from running the same operation, potentially with slightly higher fees to offset relevant transport/import taxes. They ran marketplaces at crazy prices before, like shipping to Australia before local distribution centres.
- frereubu 6y agoBecause it's still entirely unclear what the arrangements for trade will be, despite the fact that the transition agreement ends on 31st December. For example, the UK government are planning a number of huge lorry parks near the English Channel crossings to deal with new customs arrangements, whatever they may be, but they've only bought one location so far: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2020/jul/12/local-anger-over-plans-for-post-brexit-lorry-park-at-ashford https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2020/jul/12/local-anger... Edit: to be clearer about what my point is, Amazon relies enormously on friction-free shipping. It might make more sense for them to plan not to ship across a border for a while until it becomes clear what the logistics will be of shipping across that border, rather than guessing what it will be like and getting it horribly wrong. The possible outcomes range from a decent free-trade agreement with minimal disruption (although that seems vanishingly unlikely now) to a hard Brexit (i.e. no agreement) and an immediate sharp stop to frictionless cross-border trade.
- RantyDave 6y agoThe paperwork is going to be a nightmare. Why wouldn't they change?
- Hamuko 6y agoDoesn't Amazon not deliver to Switzerland or something? I think I heard that Swiss people for example can't order from Amazon.co.jp. Meanwhile I can order from Amazon.co.jp to Finland and Amazon (or DHL) handles everything from shipping to VAT and to customs declaration.
- CaptainZapp 6y agoI could be off, but here's what I recall: A couple years ago Switzerland changed the rules that companies shipping to Switzerland must collect and administer Swiss VAT and companies the size of Amazon said fuck it! and thus don't ship from the US any more. I suspect that the same goes for Amazon Japan.
- eisa01 6y agoThat sounds very strange. Norway is in a similar position as Switzerland in terms of trade, and Amazon has for the past 10 years collected Norwegian VAT up front when using express shipping. This year the government mandated that international sellers registered for VAT and Amazon has registered all their local stores in Norway
- nottorp 6y agoWeird... in Romania, I can order from Amazon US with expedited shipping and they'll charge me for VAT and DHL will handle customs for me. Or I can order with slow cheap shipping and stand in line and pay VAT myself at the post office. Either way, they will (mostly) ship. What's different with Switzerland?
- AnssiH 6y agoI believe they theoretically could, but I guess they don't consider it cost-effective, or are waiting to see what happens, or they are already planning to do it but it will take much more time. Regarding your "shipping to Australia" example - that is just regular fulfillment of Amazon.com orders from US stock, with an international destination address. That will continue to work in all EU/UK marketplaces, this change is only about fulfilling e.g. amazon.de orders from UK stock and vice-versa (EFN) and cross-border movement of not-yet-sold stock (Pan-European FBA). Regarding EFN: There is already a similar cross-border program called Amazon Global Store, where Amazon ships e.g. US stock to amazon.co.uk buyers (example: https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00AFTQ4X8 https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00AFTQ4X8). It also works for 3rd-party sellers, in which case Amazon buys the item for itself in US and then ships it to the customer in UK ("Allow Amazon to buy my products to sell globally" in Amazon US seller settings). However, this is much more limited in scope of products compared to what EFN currently is, and those items do not currently ship "internationally" (e.g. I can't order a Global Store item from amazon.co.uk to Finland like I can with EFN items). Regarding Pan-European FBA: I believe Amazon does not want to move non-sold 3rd-party stock across customs jurisdictions, or at least it has never done that before. Shipping sold items to end-customers (which they do, e.g. Australia example above) is a bit easier, as e.g. valuing the items is easy (it is exactly the amount the customer paid), and Amazon never has to be at the receiving end.
- libertine 6y agoI think that besides taxes and fees, the main issue - and bottleneck - will be customs. In EU you have free movement of goods and people, so if I buy from Amazon DE, FR, IT, the item will be shipped and moved around EU territory and easily get delivered to my door. If I buy from Amazon.com I'll get an email from the customs where they ask me for proof of purchase where the proper taxation/custom fees were paid. This is what will happen in with products coming from the UK. This means the package is being processed by a foreign entity with no time window to be released (because part of it will depend on you as well). Amazon simply cannot keep UK in their european fulfillment network warehouses because it will have items go through customs. It would be a bottleneck in a seamless movement of products. It's not about geography, it's about crossing borders.
- tannhaeuser 6y agoMy guess is that, if not for something else, Amazon and others are left with no choice other than to prepare for the worst now (or yesterday, actually), since there seems to be no progress on the rules for not-so-future EU/UK trade.