4 ms·
I am the kind of person to submit 30 ideas to internal innovation challenges. I was an innovation intern for a bank. I have won many innovation awards from comp
by MattGaiser 6y ago
I am the kind of person to submit 30 ideas to internal innovation challenges. I was an innovation intern for a bank. I have won many innovation awards from competitions they hosted to find ideas.
How many of those ideas got out of the page/prototype stage? 0.
Because it seems like the important thing for many is to seem innovative. After that part has been done, interest disappears.
Everyone would rather you excite them with a new idea. So much of this "innovation" stuff is about media and being trendy.
- hinkley 6y agoDopamine is a hell of a drug.
- MattGaiser 6y agoNever thought of myself as a drug dealer...
- maffydub 6y agoIt's possible you were the addict rather than the dealer. :( What's the easiest way of keeping you at the company rather than going to innovate somewhere else? Make it as easy as possible for you to get your next "hit" of innovation dopamine. (I'm being cynical - this isn't necessarily what your employer was doing, but it could have been.)
- MattGaiser 6y agoI must admit, that is plausible given how my current organization works.
- hinkley 6y agoI worked with a customer who was a little too dim to appreciate how manipulative he was being. Remember, it’s the boss who puts you into that position. Only they have to understand what you’re doing, and not even that well. Realizing that about him made it feel worse somehow.
- the-dude 6y agoBraincrack : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0sHCQWjTrJ8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0sHCQWjTrJ8
- iandinwoodie 6y agoWaterproof hairdryer. You can dry your hair in the shower while you get it wet.
- MattGaiser 6y agoShall we? http://www.ycombinator.com/apply/ http://www.ycombinator.com/apply/
- hathym 6y ago> Waterproof hairdryer. You can dry your hair in the shower while you get it wet. Or you can use hydrophobic nano coating
- seibelj 6y agoWell your first mistake was working for a bank. These are notoriously against innovation of any sort!
- MattGaiser 6y agoThis one was a smaller regional (50 billion CAD) bank that swaps between seeing the writing on the wall (oblivion in a globalising world) and periodically firing the innovation team. There is so much to improve and none of it seemed to ever happen.
- natch 6y agoI distrust those activities. I feel it is sometimes an IP grab by the company, which wants to give its staff fewer reasons to leave and start new (competing or not) companies. Once an idea is recorded and time stamped internally, it is effectively dead for use by anyone leaving the company. Or at least has an elevated risk. You don’t even have to be the one who submitted the idea to end up being hung up by the fact that your previous day job can claim a stake (even a weak one due to not having acted) in all these related ideas.
- MattGaiser 6y agoMy perspective is a bit different. I have thousands and thousands of ideas. I can never meaningfully act on most of them. So why not turn them into a couple hundred bucks for a page or two of writing? I have some ideas I quietly research and do not reveal that I may want to turn into a startup one day, but those are just a few of all of them. For example, my winning capstone project idea during my banking internship was in the mental health space. I have won other prizes in the professional mental health space as well. My interest in ever being in that space beyond ideation is 0 so I am not giving away anything that has other value to me.
- natch 6y ago>thousands of ideas Yeah me too. It’s a curse... wish I could focus on just one more often. Things I’ve “invented” in my mind only include mesh networking in 1997 (people thought I was crazy... why would someone share their bandwidth?). Actually submitted that one internally to a company that had the wherewithal and positioning to do it, a multi billion dollar idea, and they said “nope.” That company is now barely a wisp of a shadow of the behemoth it once was. I’m of the school of thought that it’s the doing that counts, and I respect it when someone brings things past a finish line. Anyway nice that you’ve found a fun and rewarding outlet for some of yours.
- LoSboccacc 6y agosame, I wrote a nosql in 2004 it used XML on the api because json wasn't even a thing back then and I didn't even realize it was innovative it just felt the right solution for a customer's problem
- refurb 6y agoMy experience while working at a massive company was similar. Lots of talk about innovation. They were even willing to fund the ideas. What kills most of it is the execution, and I'm not talking about the tech side, I'm talking about working within the hidebound structure of a massive organization and all the rules created for the current business. Need to tweak a policy slightly so you can actually execute? Get ready for a 6 month slog arguing for the change with legal, compliance, finance, etc. I remember working on an innovative idea were were partnering with an external firm on. Took 8 months just to get the ok to proceed.
- MattGaiser 6y agoToo many companies are built with the mentality of a greedy programming algorithm.
- kristopolous 6y agoFor me, the biggest survival filter is when I price things out. Almost invariably I find the product idea to be more expensive then I consider a reasonable price. The next stage of death is the marketing. I've gone through about 25 marketing books, careful notes, annotations, etc, and honestly it's still the most common place of death. Money helps a lot here. So if you want that then go back to stage 1 and see if the price still works. Then the things that pass that have logistics hurdles in the facilitation of the demand. There's delays, quality slippage, customer relations, it's not easy. You may get caught with a large stock and demand slips and you have to figure out storage, that's an additional cost on things that haven't even sold yet. Ackk.. The details are where the death is. Innovation exists outside of all of this. Every now and then I hear about someone that went from innovation to product, experienced zero of these issues and just sailed in on easy street. Those people are just lottery winners by another name. Screw them, that's not common reality. The world has randomness, it can be favorable, luck is something very real. The hard knock strategies to modest success where you're not worrying yourself to sleep every night don't make sexy stories but it's the 99%. Expect nothing less.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoIdeas cost nothing.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoSame, however I am witnessing one take off to disrupt a 9-figure industry. This won’t change my high 5-figure salary though :) I like being in a big corporation because of the low risk lifestyle it entails, lots of time with the family!