7 ms·
Corporations aren't really meant to be all that innovative. In practice corporations are designed to be extremely disposable. They can be unwound up on failure
by roenxi 6y ago
Corporations aren't really meant to be all that innovative. In practice corporations are designed to be extremely disposable. They can be unwound up on failure and spun up relatively easily. There isn't a rule saying that these companies can't innovate, but why should Cisco even be trying to write a teleconference client? There is no fault to be found that they didn't capitalise on what became Zoom.
Best of breed corporations are often characterised by a focus on key ideas and their variations - look at Apple, pretty much all their products are variants of an iPad at different sizes and different target audiences. Picking some other global Fortune 500s: Walmart and Amazon, profound dedication to logistics. DuPont knows chemistry, Boeing mastered turbulence and propulsion. A couple of big extractors that know how to claim resources from the natural world. These companies are all very innovative, but also profoundly focused. They will really struggle to cope with innovations that aren't in the area of their strategic edge.
It isn't a loss to anyone if the next trillion-dollar idea spins out as a new company instead of growing within an existing major. If someone has great ideas, we should invest in the person not in their employer. And they should stand to profit from their own success.
- kqr 6y agoWell, Apple didn't start out making iPads in a garage. Amazon didn't start out renting web services along with books. I think you're selling some of these companies short -- the thing they might seem focused on now was not the thing they initially got popular for doing. In other words, they innovated outside their expertise to stay relevant.
- roenxi 6y agoI don't think it is a failure of Cisco that they let Zoom slip out and become a new company. Even if I were a Cisco shareholder I don't know that I'd be that unhappy with management. I can just buy Zoom stock if I think they are on a winner - more than 75% of their market cap came into existence after the IPO. I don't see who the loser is in this story. It isn't Cisco shareholders; they can be Zoom shareholders too if they want to be.
- MattGaiser 6y agoCisco shareholders lost as they should have had the value of Zoom as part of their existing shares. The loss is in having to buy it separately.
- roenxi 6y agoI'd have made more money buying Zoom at IPO than I would if I held Cisco at the same time but added Zoom to Cisco's market cap. There was a big opportunity here for investors. Sure Cisco shareholders would have been better off if Zoom was an in-house project, but investors are really the ones who are supposed to be making the value calls on teleconference-or-routers market exposure style decisions. If I'm a Cisco shareholder I don't think management made a mistake. I think I made a mistake not becoming a Zoom shareholder.
- aidanlister 6y agoOkay, you both made a mistake then. Your mistake does not lessen Cisco’s mistake.
- quicklime 6y agoIt’s not just that. Cisco shareholders lost as they should have had the value of webex as part of their existing shares. This is being lost as zoom takes over.
- konschubert 6y agoThe problem only occurs if the assumption of inventing zoom was priced into the cisco stock. If Cisco is priced at a multiple of earnings then shareholders get a totally fine deal and can invest their leftover money into startups.
- hedora 6y agoI own some cisco stock. I have to use webex at work. I suspect a significant percentage of cisco’s shareholders are in the same boat. I want them to fire the management chain that was involved in the zoom debacle, and also fire the people that hired / promoted that management chain.
- 11thEarlOfMar 6y agoI've given this some thought and developed a notion that I hope to actually implement. Critique welcome. Large companies can identify innovators, or at least learn to do so. In some cases, it will be as obvious as the founders of companies they've acquired. In other cases, it may be simply polling the engineering and product management ranks and tracking down those who are considered innovative by their peers. Or, you may even make it egalitarian and offer developers a 'year of invention' after some number of years at the company. One point I think is key is to create an environment that is conducive to innovation. Relaxed administrative obligations, flat organization structure and a budget. Nominal oversight and justification requirements. Then, a simple guideline: What is developed needs to be on a path to becoming a product or service the company could offer. Innovators could be supported with HR for finding contractors or consultants to work with, purchasing for buying components or equipment, marketing and business development persons could be assigned to the program to help innovators with business plans, cost and pricing analysis, market research. The innovation organization could be placed in a work space with dedicated space for their project, and a common space to meet and collaborate with other innovators. Rewards for successful products could simply be additional stock grants and recognition, or perhaps simply another tour of innovation. The risks would be if the program were abused and budget misspent, or the innovator simply didn't do any real work, or went off the rails with their projects. Also, development projects could have many budget sizes from virtually nothing to multiple millions. Perhaps the business development partner could help with proposals to request additional budget, once prototypes were far enough along to be compelling. A multi-billion corporation could easily allocate a few million to this type of environment and keep a dozen or so innovators busy. You'd only need one success every so often to make it worthwhile.
- MattGaiser 6y agoAlso, time. A year should be a year, not two week periods with endless "how's it going?" and check in meetings where you need something to present.
- kochthesecond 6y agoUgh.. This hits too close to home.
- jariel 6y ago"In practice corporations are designed to be extremely disposable." Opposite - they are designed to be incumbent. Once a product sticks, companies become 'operational' and not 'dynamic' which is to say they excel at customer, product, regulatory, lobbying, scale, RFPs, branding, little features that satisfy a range of customers. Everything done 'just well enough' but otherwise the entity has not reason to innovate. Innovation is just a pile of risk to the system, when in fact, the 'incumbent corporation' is a 'cog' in that system so there's no reason to change it. Not only is there little incentive to change, there is 'anti incentive' in many cases. Also - innovators are really hard to identify, and that thing may not be part of the job anyhow. There are all kinds of creative innovators, with many kinds of specialisation, the Zoom case I'm not sure is very exemplary anyhow.
- jierenchen 6y agoSame reaction here: "How is this a problem?" I think it's in the nature of big companies to view everything as a process optimization problem and losing out on "innovators" is viewed as a gap in optimality that needs to be filled. An environment tuned to value extraction is inherently going to be hostile to exploration. Can't have your cake and eat it too, buddy.
- netcan 6y agoI disagree. Corporations, in practice, aren't that. They are not disposable in practice. Large companies dominate their markets, expect to live forever, etc. Innovations that don't happen within Google, microsoft, etc... those innovations don't happen. This isn't an absolute statement. Innovations can happen outside and new companies can be founded. We went through a period in internet-based innovations where a lot of innovation happened outside of existing large corporations and became their own giant corporations. That's not a long term norm though. That reality was largely driven by really low capital costs. These days, new internet companies raise a lot more money... mostly to pay for advertising that goes to google and facebook, who control access to users. More likely than innovation outside of existing companies gets bought into bigger ones. Consider Tesla. Obviously Musk's abilities played a big part. So did his bank account, his ability to raise capital, etc. It takes that much force to innovate in that market from outside. Very difficult. I think it's reasonable to ask why existing car companies couldn't pull off anything like it. There are incentive/incumbent reasons, but I don't think these are the whole story. I agree that innovation should and could come from outside big corporations. But, the reality is that resources, market power and such are highly concentrated within large corporations. There isn't much space to operate outside of it. We can't expect a sub-1% section of an industry to do all the innovation... outside of rare examples like the internet circa 1995-2015. Also, consider that tech giants are a lot more innovative than incumbents in other industries, largely because of the pressure from small companies and their relative youth. Trains, Planes, Cars, Roads, Banking, smelting, etc... these industries are not like that. Nothing at all happens outside of large corporations, innovative or otherwise.
- roenxi 6y ago> I think it's reasonable to ask why existing car companies couldn't pull off anything like it... Usually I leave comments alone unless I agree or disagree, but this is a really easy one to answer - the entire Tesla experiment has been grossly unprofitable so far and there isn't any concrete evidence that any business should follow in Tesla's footsteps. They just posted their first measly profit after a decade with not much to show for it. It may yet come good and it has been a good ride for shareholders, but if you want to know why nobody is rushing to innovate like Tesla it is because they have been leaking money like a drunken sailor.
- Waterfall 6y agoI'm surprised you didn't mention Bell Laboratories at all. They innovated a lot, and created a ton of stuff including Claude Shannon's paper and a lot of the technology today we use. Boeing I would say has a lot to learn from SpaceX. >If someone has great ideas, we should invest in the person not in their employer. But what if the employer is investing? This talks about how corporations dismiss good ideas, but large ones like Bell fostered it. Not sure if Apple had some innovators leave, but if they did, I haven't heard of them.
- lazylizard 6y agoOr thermo electron
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoChris Lattner, Tony Fadell, and Scott Forstall probably count as innovators, and they all left Apple. Bell Labs was a classic blue sky internal research outfit. Modern corporate culture can't quite handle the concept, so modern R&D is more constrained and "results driven." There's a critical difference between implementing existing ideas and inventing completely new classes of ideas and devices - like the transistor, or information theory as a discipline. Modern corps do a lot of the former, but not so much of the latter. Far less than Bell Labs used to.
- Waterfall 6y agoWhat have they made since? Forestall makes plays now doesn't he? I don't know the other 2 of the top of my head