7 ms·
> I'll be impressed the day I can see a program that can 1) only rely on its own limited experiential inputs Hasn't the typical human taken in orders of magnit
by colordrops 6y ago
> I'll be impressed the day I can see a program that can 1) only rely on its own limited experiential inputs
Hasn't the typical human taken in orders of magnitude more data than this example? And the data has been of both direct sensory experience and texts from other people as well.
- abernard1 6y ago> Hasn't the typical human taken in orders of magnitude more data than this example? Have you read GPT-3s 175 billion parameters (words, sentences, papers, I don't care) of anything? Do you know all the words used in that corpus? Nobody has or does. A child of a small age can listen to a very small set of things and not just come up with words to communicate with mama and papa what they learned, but they can reuse it. And this I think is key, because the language part of that is at least partially secondarily. The little kid understands what they're talking about even if they have a hard time communicating it to an adult. The fact they take creative leaps to use their extremely limited vocabulary to communicate their knowledge is amazing.
- ipnon 6y agoI recall a researcher filming their child from the day they were born until they began to speak. They wanted to find how many times a child had to hear a word in order to be able to repeat it back to the parent. The result, I think, was that if the child heard the word 2,000 times at all, they would be able to repeat it. But, if they heard the word 600 times at the same place, for instance the end of the couch, that would be enough to repeat it. The human brain requires less training, but to some extent it is pretrained by our genetic code. The human brain will take on a predictable structure with any sort of training. This post was generated using GPT-3. [;)]
- sah2ed 6y ago> I recall a researcher filming their child from the day they were born until they began to speak. Can’t tell if you are kidding or not, but if you aren’t, mind sharing links about the researcher for the curious?
- ipnon 6y agoLet me take a look, I was not kidding. I recall some mainstream media coverage in the last decade. edit: Can't seem to find it which is a shame. I think it may have been included in a TED talk.
- abernard1 6y ago> This post was generated using GPT-3. [;)] Your post was generated using GPT-3 and 175 billion parameters of pre-existing human writing, contextualized, distilled, and cross-referenced with terminology we've agreed on for centuries. It's a parrot, and I remain unimpressed. Take the learned knowledge of GPT-3 (because it must be so smart right?) and have it actually do something. Buy stocks, make chemical formulas, build planes. If you are not broke or dead by the end of that exercise, I'll be impressed and believe GPT-3 knows things.
- kevmo314 6y ago> That post was generated using GPT-3 and 175 billion parameters of pre-existing human writing, contextualized, distilled, and cross-referenced with terminology we've agreed on for centuries. So basically like DNA?
- saberience 6y agoDNA is nothing like the training of GPT. DNA does not encord a massive amount of statistics of words and language and how concepts, words, etc, relate to one another. All DNA does it encode for how to grow, build, and mantain a human body. That human body has the potential to learn a language and communicate, but if you put a baby human inside an empty room and drop in food, it will never learn language and never communicate. DNA isn't magic and comparing "millions of years of evolution" of DNA is nothing like the Petabytes of data that GPT-3 needs to operate. Again DNA has no knowledge embedded in it, it has no words or data embedded. Data in the sense that we imagine Wikipedia stored in JSON files on a hard disk. DNA stores an algorithm for growth of a human, that's it. The GPT-3 model is probably > 700GB in size. That is, for GPT to be able to generate text it needs an absolutely massive "memory" of existing text which it can recite verbatim. In contrast, young human children can generate more novel insights with many orders of magnitude less data in "memory" and less training time.
- varjag 6y agoSince literacy or human knowledge isn't encoded in DNA, it's nothing like it.
- 6y ago
- peterthehacker 6y agoI think that it’s the opposite. This algorithm requires many examples of text on the specific topic. Probably more than most humans would require. > While typically task-agnostic in architecture, this method still requires task-specific fine-tuning datasets of thousands or tens of thousands of examples [0] I don’t know what constitutes an example in this case but let’s assume it means 1 blog article. I don’t know many humans that read thousands or tens of thousands of blog articles on a specific topic. And if I did I’d expect that human to write a much more interesting article. To me, this and other similar generated texts from OpenAI feel bland / generic. Take a listen to the generated music from OpenAI - https://openai.com/blog/jukebox/ https://openai.com/blog/jukebox/. It’s pretty bad, but in a weird way. It’s technically correct - in key, on beat, ect. And even some of the music it generates is technically hard to do, but it sounds so painfully generic. > All the impressive achievements of deep learning amount to just curve fitting Judea Perl [1] This comment was written by a human :) [0]https://arxiv.org/abs/2005.14165 https://arxiv.org/abs/2005.14165 [1]https://www.quantamagazine.org/to-build-truly-intelligent-machines-teach-them-cause-and-effect-20180515/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/to-build-truly-intelligent-ma...
- t_von_doom 6y ago> assume it means 1 blog article I'd like to play devils advocate here. Given one blog article in a foreign language: Would a human be able to write coherent future articles? With no teacher or context whatsoever how many articles would one have to read before they could write something that would 'fool' a native speaker? 1000, 100,000? I have no idea how to measure the quantity/quality of contextual and sensory data we are constantly processing from just existing in the real world, however, it is vital to solving these tasks in a human way - yet it is a dataset that no machine has access to I would argue comparing 'like for like' disregards the rich data we swim amongst as humans, making it an unfair comparison
- ianhorn 6y agoGPT-3 was trained on half a trillion words (common crawl, webtext, two book corpuses, and wikipedia, IIRC). At about 100 words per minute, that's almost ten thousand years of continuous speech. By my estimate it's probably a few thousand times what people actually hear in a lifetime. We don't experience nearly the volume of language that it did.
- fsflover 6y agoYou forgot that we also absorb a much larger set of data through other senses.
- abernard1 6y agoAbsolutely 100% agree. Why then, the continued obsession with building single-media models? Is focusing on the Turing test and language proficiency bringing us further away from the goals of legitimate intelligence? I would argue "yes", which was my original comment. At no point in us trying to replicate what an adult sounds like have we actually demonstrated anything remotely like the IQ of a small child. And there's this big gap where it's implied by some that this process goes 1) sound like an adult -> 2) think like an adult, which seems to be missing the boat imo. (There's logically this intermediate step where we have this adult-sounding monster AI child.) If we could constrain the vocabulary to that a child might be exposed to, the correlative trickery of these models would be more obvious. The (exceptionally good) quality of these curve fits wouldn't trick us with vocabulary and syntax that looks like something we'd say. The dumb things would sound dumb, and the smart things would sound smart. And maybe, probably even, that would require us fusing in all sorts of other experiential models to make that happen.
- ianhorn 6y ago> Why then, the continued obsession with building single-media models? I think it's literally just working with available data. With some back of the envelope math, GPT-3's training corpus is thousands of lifetimes of language heard. All else equal, I'm sure the ML community would almost unanimously agree that thousands of lifetimes of other data with many modes of interaction and different media would be better. It would take forever to do and would cost insane amounts of money. But some kinds of labels are relatively cheap, and some data don't need labels at all, like this internet text corpus. I think that explains the obsession with single-media models. There's a lot more work to do and this is, believe it or not, still the low hanging fruit.