4 ms·
Conspiracy Theories, Denial, and the Coronavirus
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agohttp://archive.is/x5qgg http://archive.is/x5qgg
- henriquez 6y agoHow can you really argue with the thesis that anyone who argues with the thesis is a denialist and a conspiracy theorist? It takes a special kind of elitism to assume a conclusion from an unposed argument as a premise for an opinion piece likening public policy disagreements to genocide, all the while with no sense of irony hand-wringing about partisan media outlets and institutional decay. People like this author are exactly why the tenor of our national discourse has gone off the rails into crazy territory. Well-traveled, well-educated and blinded by their own arrogance.
- panpanna 6y agoIf you have a thesis that goes against well established facts and you meet that by not re-evaluating your stance but by blaming the media for not supporting your altered facts, then yes you are a conspiracy theorist. I don't see where "elitism" comes in here. When you are wrong, you are wrong.
- EliRivers 6y agoIt seems that reality (that is, the narrative of events supported by facts and evidence, the things that actually happened) and truth are no longer the same. As Henriquez inadvertently makes clear, he doesn't need to address the facts. He can simply say that his course of events is just as valid as that of the "elites", with their "evidence" and "facts". He can (and does) dress it up with bullshit wordy adjectives, and he can (and does) make it somehow not even about the facts, not even about reality, but instead about some kind of weird fucked up culture war. You'll note he doesn't mention facts even once; the very idea of evidence isn't present. Those who deal in fact, the people he rails against, are powerless when people ascribe zero weight to those facts.
- henriquez 6y agoI have not denied any facts or reality, yet you attack personally while missing my point. Here, to clarify: 1. Does the coronavirus pandemic exist? Yes. 2. Has it killed a lot of people? Obviously. My point is that how we respond to that threat is a public policy debate. The author of this piece doesn’t make his position clear or offer evidence either, instead he simply compares disagreement with his preferred consensus to a genocide and related coverup, all the while drawing parallels to “some kind of weird fucked up culture war” (as you put it) and vaguely posing the “how did we even come to this” drama trope. “disagreement == genocide”; statements like that are how we’ve come to this and why we face the institutional decay the author decries. TFA is arguing in bad faith pure and simple. That’s why facts aren’t relevant here, not to be confused with facts don’t matter. Facts matter, but you don’t argue with [not an argument].
- EliRivers 6y agoGenuine question; did that atrocity happen? Was it real? I know what I think, but maybe you disagree.
- henriquez 6y agoYou’re asking if I believe in genocide against Muslims?
- EliRivers 6y agoI guess your refusal to actually answer that straight, simple question says it all.
- henriquez 6y agoI was just trying to clarify your actual question after spending two posts explaining why genocide is not relevant to U.S. public policy (or at least how this particular article fails to establish so). To answer, I wasn’t there, I don’t know but based on the information available I assume it _did_ happen.
- PrefixKitten 6y agoAre you saying that the author of this article is a conspiracy theorist?
- Nasrudith 6y agoGenerically quite easily - use actual evidence that the thesis isn't accurate. It gets harder when proof is fuzzier but unfalsifiability should be in itself a useful hook. To give an easy to disprove example if someone claims that the very existence police brutality is a conspiracy theory from criminals and their apologists and is denying the existence of criminals it would be trivial to list a long list of police brutality cases and just listing the definition of "excessive force" doesn't deny the existence of criminals.
- henriquez 6y agoYou’re correct generically but what I’m referring to in this particular article is a rhetorical feedback loop. The basic structure of the argument is as follows: 1. Genocide occurred 2. Serbs created cultural trope around genocide denialism (bad) 3. American response to coronavirus is like 2 The article presents a very thoughtful analysis of an atrocity that occurred followed by a collective denial, but it falls completely short in presenting a parallel to American culture / current events (point 3). This is where the feedback loop comes into play. The author asserts that our pandemic response is similar to a genocide, but he doesn’t establish _how_, which would actually be the most crucial detail if this were a good-faith argument and not an emotional appeal wrapped as intellect porn. Without establishing _how_, it is left to the reader to fill in the details. What exactly about the situation in America is like genocide in Bosnia? In order to do piece this together, the reader must assume the conclusion (3) as a premise and work backwards. The piece falls entirely flat because it starts as a passionate and well-presented takedown of consensus reality underpinned by mass denialism, and ends with a metaphor that can only hold true if the reader adopts a particular consensus reality. It’s left as a challenge to the reader to fill in a reality that supports the author’s comparison to genocide. Our virtue is at stake because we all agree that genocide is bad. But that’s not a real argument.
- 082349872349872 6y ago> "The glorification of convicted war criminals, the denial of genocide and war crimes, and bitter disputes around conflicting commemorations all create an environment of perpetual division that is gradually becoming the norm." Taking the specific example of (as it was then) yugoslavia, an environment of freshly perpetual division (stoked in those times mainly by radio and TV) was what started the bloodshed. I know refugees whose conspiracy theory is that that division had been helped by outside forces. I think they're optimists, and Solzhenitsyn called it more accurately: > “If only there were evil people somewhere insidiously committing evil deeds, and it were necessary only to separate them from the rest of us and destroy them. But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23613311 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23613311