3 ms·
Well, given that we don't have a complete 'technical' definition of consciousness, I don't think it's unfair to say that it can still be argued whether dogs hav
by tsimionescu 6y ago
Well, given that we don't have a complete 'technical' definition of consciousness, I don't think it's unfair to say that it can still be argued whether dogs have consciousness in the same sense that humans do, even though no one would argue that it's OK to torture a dog.
For example, even some of the simplest animals show recognizable signs of suffering when hurt (writhing, certain stress hormones, avoidance, etc.). Even plants show some signs of stress when hurt, and avoidance of the area where that happened.
Should we conclude from that plants and all animals are conscious in the same sense that we are? If they are not, how should we interpret these signs? Is there a spectrum of consciousness? Or are there 2 separate properties, 1 related to certain complex analyses of stimuli that is essentially the same at least in all animals, from nematodes to humans, and 2 that is specific to humans, that has to do with constructing an entire mental world that is a model of the external world, or with something else entirely?