5 ms·
that's something I never understood about US politics, what prevented Sanders from creating its own party for the US election and not run for the democratic pri
by baby 6y ago
that's something I never understood about US politics, what prevented Sanders from creating its own party for the US election and not run for the democratic primaries?
- keiferski 6y agoHe easily could but would end up taking votes from the Democrats, thus helping his opponent in the process. The American system doesn’t work well with third-party candidates and mostly incentivizes against them; see the 1992 election for a recent example.
- refurb 6y agoOk, but in Canada a new upstart Conservative party (Reform) took away Votes from the existing Conservative Party (PC) and over several elections eventually got a majority. So sure, Bernie might take away votes from the Democrats, but that doesn’t mean support will eventually shift to him.
- keiferski 6y agoMuch more money and resources at play in the U.S., and Bernie is also fairly old and doesn't really have a 'party' or a clear successor. He/his followers wouldn't gain much from starting a new party.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoTwo things: 1. The media would ignore him if he did. He wouldn't get to take part in any of the debates, and most people would have no idea he was even running. 2. It might not even be possible for him to get on the ballot in most states as a third-party candidate. Election laws make it nearly impossible for third parties to get on the ballot in many states. In the last 20 years, the Green Party has never managed to get on the ballot in more than 45 states. In 2004, they only managed to get on the ballot in half the states. The Democratic party fights tooth and nail to keep them off the ballot (just like the Republican party fights to keep the Libertarians off the ballot). Because almost all the local and state election officials and judges are Democrats and Republicans, the deck is stacked against third parties. Finally, Sanders would be viewed as a spoiler, robbing votes from the Democratic party. Most people would feel like they would be throwing their votes away.
- wolco 6y agoThird parties tend to emerge when one party has been in too long and has a large percentage of the vote. New party tries to take 30% of the 70% and 10% of the 30%
- md_ 6y agoThe primary attribute of American politics that encourages a two party system is what’s known as “first past the post” elections. America’s two main parties have changed over the years (remember the Whigs?), so the existence of a two-party system cannot be attributed purely to control exerted by the current two parties. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger%27s_law.
- bobthepanda 6y agoAnother, often overlooked part, is that competing in an American election requires very expensive media and outreach campaigns. Clinton spent $1.2B in 2016 and Trump spent $680B. These are formidable sums for non-establishment parties. Bernie spent $230M in a primary. To give a rough comparison, the UK limits spending per constituency, so the upper limit a party is allowed to spend in the UK is 19.5 GBP.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Trump spent $680B I think this is not true. > the upper limit a party is allowed to spend in the UK is 19.5 GBP I'm pretty sure they spend more than that, as well.
- bobthepanda 6y agothe B is a typo, should be M. > I'm pretty sure they spend more than that, as well. As per the BBC: https://www.bbc.com/news/election-2019-50170067 https://www.bbc.com/news/election-2019-50170067 > In the 2017 general election, 75 parties and 18 campaign groups reported spending more than £41.6m between them. The Conservatives spent most at £18.6m. It fielded 638 candidates, winning in 317 constituencies. Labour came in at £11m and the Liberal Democrats at £6.8m.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> As per the BBC The BBC figures are a million times larger than yours if you meant it as a total, and a hundred times smaller than yours if you meant it as per-capita.
- bmn__ 6y agoCGP Grey - The Problems with First Past the Post Voting Explained (section The Spoiler Effect): https://youtu.be/s7tWHJfhiyo?t=300 https://youtu.be/s7tWHJfhiyo?t=300 http://enwp.org/Ralph_Nader#Spoiler_controversy http://enwp.org/Ralph_Nader#Spoiler_controversy
- auganov 6y agoHe's a Democrat senator and got Biden to essentially support most of his platform. Running as an independent or 3rd party would be political suicide and wouldn't help his agenda. But aside from that most countries have a single process to get on the ballot country-wide. In US you'd have to navigate this process for each state. I'm sure Bernie could pull that off. But it is definitely the reason you see many fewer randoms making a dent. Also if you consider the way primaries work in both parties it's way more transparent and approachable than most other places. Many major parties around the world don't have a primary process at all. And even when they do it's usually limited to insiders. So if you want to change things you're almost forced to create a party by default. If you couldn't make it in a primary of a party that's closer to your beliefs than the general population - how can you expect to make it on a national level?