6 ms·
"If a tree falls in the forest and nobody is around to hear it, does it make a sound?" Similar thing here. A mystery is a concept which can only occur within h
by HPsquared 6y ago
"If a tree falls in the forest and nobody is around to hear it, does it make a sound?"
Similar thing here. A mystery is a concept which can only occur within human consciousness.
- jcims 6y agoAny time i see an -est superlative in a sciency article i just inject my own ‘known’ or ‘discovered’ as appropriate. Makes everything more palatable.
- chrisweekly 6y agoArguably, the Universe can also only exist within consciousness.
- namero999 6y agoIndeed, this is the next Copernican revolution which can't come soon enough. So many things make much more sense the moment we swap primacy of matter with primacy of consciousness.
- vidarh 6y agoThe distinction is largely moot unless we discover a way to pierce the veil. The strongest argument for modern materialism (in the philosophical sense of the term) is that it doesn't matter if it is true unless we discover a way to observe or interact with something beyond - as long as all we observe is a materialist representation of the world, we have no other meaningful choice than to act as if it is true, because we can but guess at what else might exist and the options are infinite.
- namero999 6y agoI would tend to agree with what you say here, with some clarifications. The first one is that I think it's a matter of _models_. What I mean is that digging under the surface of materialism, what we'll find is pure physics, and currently physics is based on incomplete models or models based on unreachable or non-interactive constructs. Many-universes, 26 dimensions, dark energy, collapse of wave function... Placeholder ideas to make the math work. So, idealism is preaching that there could be the possibility that our current holes in knowledge and understanding might be filled with mind stuff rather than matter stuff. Sure, it might require us to flip the causality relationship between the two, but I don't see that as a fundamentally different way of guessing at what else might exist, and just as materialism has descriptive and predictive power based on abstract, unreachable constructs, so can an idealist worldview. With regards of having to act as if materialism must be true, I would agree but it depends on at which scale we operate. Meaning, I doubt there could be any other functioning paradigm to go about our daily life and to progress practical science. But for things such as "why is there stuff instead of not" or even more tricky questions such as "what's the meaning", I'd look elsewhere.
- jordwest 6y ago> The distinction is largely moot unless we discover a way to pierce the veil. Buddhists might tell you we've already discovered a way to pierce the veil ("enlightenment"). Recently I saw a video of Shinzen Young [0] describing his experience of this, and it sounds a lot like this observation of something beyond. Regardless of whether it's really seeing the nature of reality or just a trick of the brain, I find it fascinating that so many people (throughout history) have very similar [1] experiences and it's given me a lot of motivation to meditate more... [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPnLDtHLymo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPnLDtHLymo [1] https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/what-does-it-feel-like-to-be-enlightened/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/what-does-i...
- DennisP 6y agoWithin some consciousness, anyway. There might be others out there.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoumm, yes. Yes it does.
- namero999 6y agoNo, it doesn't. It says 'sound' as opposed to 'a certain amount of air being displaced'. It makes no sound.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound "In physics, sound is a vibration that propagates as an acoustic wave, through a transmission medium such as a gas, liquid or solid" "In human physiology and psychology, sound is the reception of such waves and their perception by the brain" I guess it depends on your definition.
- namero999 6y agoI am quite sure the formal definition of sound is something we are all familiar with in here. I would argue that the point of the question is whether there could be sound without the conscious experience of sound. When a tree falls there is definitely displacement of air. Displacement of air though has no intrinsic quality of 'sound-ness'. Such quality can only be experienced by consciousness.
- baddox 6y agoIf you’re redefining the question as “if a tree falls in the woods and no one is around to hear it, does anyone hear it?” that is much easier to answer but also much less interesting.
- namero999 6y agoQuite the opposite, actually. What compelled me to tune into this thread was the fact that I've felt the question was being redefined as "if a tree falls, does it displace air or creates any sort of physical effect which we might call sound?" which I find, as I'm sure you do too, easy and uninteresting. I think the question is meant to trigger reasoning on a much more deeper level than that, namely what it is to have a conscious experience and how we should go about defining what is real from that perspective.
- krisoft 6y agoYou couldn't have illustrated my point nicer. Yes it makes a sound. There will be vibrations in the air pressure propagating from the impact. If there are birds around they might take a flight. The ground vibrations will create ripples in the nearby pond which might distract a dragonfly enough that a frog swallows it whole. I understand that I'm taking a Zen koan in the most literal sense, but this the best way I can illuminate the ludicrousness of it. We are not the centre of the everything. Things happen without us. Believing otherwise is as I wrote egoistical, self-centered. There is an unremarkable planet orbiting a regular star a thousand and two light year away from us. On that planet there is a somewhat deer-like species descendant from a prey animal. They are masters of mathematics, philosophy and technology. Their cognition is so advanced that they would only politely smile at the notion that "human consciousness" is the greatest mystery of all. One of them between two ritual playfights took a dust bath on the meadow. It was thinking about the atmosphere of gas giants, when he come up with a question. There is not even a point in trying to explain to humans what the question was. We don't have the capacity to comprehend it. That question was the greatest mystery of all. Pity that they all went extinct before coming to terms with their own inability to find their answer.
- mrmonkeyman 6y agoThing is. Without (any kind of) consciousness, what does it mean for air to propagate and birds to fly? Without it, there is literally nothing.