3 ms·
https://www.google.com/search?q=charles+tilly+war+making+state+making+organized+crime https://www.google.com/search?q=charles+tilly+war+making+sta... I found t
by forgotmypw17 6y ago
https://www.google.com/search?q=charles+tilly+war+making+state+making+organized+crime https://www.google.com/search?q=charles+tilly+war+making+sta...
I found this paper by Charles Tilly, a well-known sociologist, to be enlightening and eye-opening.
And I think the flip-side is also true, "organized crime" being little different from "legitimate state", except in scale and sometimes scale.
But even more enlightening to me, building on top of this paper, was the opinion of a chief named Bear in the Vietnamese (iirc) jungle, who had to deal with both the "legitimate" (dominant) government and the "paramilitary" groups, who would both alternate tearing through his village and terrorizing his people.
To Bear, all of this activity was the inevitable result of existence of power itself, just a fact of reality. Power which, inevitablly, one or another would struggle to acquire, with similar results regardless of who it was. This perspective allowed him to maintain and protect his tribe from both organizations, by acknowledging their power, acquiescing to it, and letting the wind bend his stalk but not break it, so to speak.
Bear was a wise man who lived to old age in a place with everyday danger, so his words are worth something, IMO.
---
I learned of Bear and his wisdom from a book written by an anthropologist who lived with his people for several years. I remember one of the stories being about how an unwanted premature baby was allowed to die, and how much this upset the anthropologist at first.
Unfortunately, I do not remember the name of the book anymore. If anyone recognizes it, please comment here.
- Bobbcatt 6y ago>And I think the flip-side is also true, "organized crime" being little different from "legitimate state", except in scale and sometimes scale. This is well known in anarchist/libertarian circle. Government taking 30% of your income is essentially a protection racket. People who are born and only lived in a stable single government state just assumes that there is something privileged about the state itself. But that's just frog-in-a-well effect.
- 082349872349872 6y ago"Lane, a superbly attentive historian of Venice, allowed specifically for the case of a government that generates protection rents for its merchants by deliberately attacking their competitors." In a more historical note, compare https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warlord_Era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warlord_Era