2 ms·
A big chunk of your taxes are not paying for the benefits you receive. At least 47% are direct wealth transfers to other people [1]. Unless you believe that the
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
A big chunk of your taxes are not paying for the benefits you receive. At least 47% are direct wealth transfers to other people [1]. Unless you believe that there is < 4% graft in the budget, that means the majority of your taxes are taken and given to other people.
The basic, vital services you need (police, fire, roads, water, government administrators, etc) amount to only 24% of the government budget and a much smaller fraction of the federal budget.
http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/piechart_2009_US_total#usgs30280 http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/piechart_2009_US_total#u...
(Education and the military make up the remainder.)
I draw a line at 50%. When >50% of your taxes are simply taken and given to others, I think it's morally legitimate to evade them.
Your morality may vary. I'd be curious to know where you draw the line. Is it ok for the government to waste 75% of your tax money? Is it ok for other organizations threatening violence to do the same? I.e., is it morally legitimate to evade Mafia protection payments if they spent 50.01% on publicly beneficial services?
[1] I'm counting SS, medicare/medicaid/etc, welfare and mortgage interest deduction as "direct wealth transfers". I don't know how to allocate interest on debt, so I'm excluding that from the total. There are probably other categories of direct wealth transfers that I didn't think of.
- lutorm 16y agoJust to make it clear, while I agree with the idea of a tax-funded government, I do have issues with specific implementations of this idea, the US budget being one of them. Your Mafia example is spurious, as it's not subject to elections. A democratic government only exists by the consent of the governed. I do not think that corporations or organized crime have taxing authority.
- mike_esspe 16y agoBy that logic - you can't tax those who don't vote, because they didn't give their consent.