3 ms·
I would like to know what the average user thinks of AMP. We techies are ok with a uncontrolled freewheeling web, but a lot of people have a problem with that a
by MattGaiser 6y ago
I would like to know what the average user thinks of AMP. We techies are ok with a uncontrolled freewheeling web, but a lot of people have a problem with that and hate that experience.
- causality0 6y agoI'm one of the less-technical and least techno-political, compared to most HN posters. I personally despise AMP for two reasons: the URLs are fugly when I send them to someone and take longer to parse when reading, and AMP hijacks my mobile browser's address bar and prevents me from accessing my tabs until I scroll all the way up the page. It's a thinly-veiled method of forcing me to look at the web page twice before closing it and I wish I could get my hands on the son of a bitch who thought it up.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rydre 6y ago> I wish I could get my hands on the son of a bitch who thought it up. Malte Ubl (@Cramforce) would like to have a word with you.
- tomgp 6y agoMy guess would be that the average user doesn’t know about AMP or have any opinion about it.
- MattGaiser 6y agoPerhaps not a overt opinion, but do they prefer using AMP sites or not? If we sat them down and had them use 5 with AMP and 5 without, which would they prefer?
- feanaro 6y agoThe answer to this should obviously depend on the chosen set of test websites. But even if there are websites where the AMP version would be preferred (and I'm sure there are), that's not the whole story. In order for a user to make an informed decision about their preference, they have to take into account the whole cost -- not just the immediately observable part of it. That includes all future ramifications of an AMP-centric future, many of which would definitely not be good for the user. So while I'm sure there are examples of egregiously bloated websites that would be superficially improved by AMP, I'm not convinced the user comes out with a net benefit.
- rapnie 6y agoFor most non-technical users this is all out-of-sight, non-existing as an issue. I am often surprised when I browse on the laptops or mobiles of friends and family, and see totally ad-infested, slow-loading crap. It is a different web than I have. When I say "Dude, what's going on here? I can improve your life. Let me install FF and an ad-blocker" they just shrug and say "Nah, its okay like this". Aboslutely frustrating.
- feanaro 6y agoWho are these people and how did you determine that they have a problem with the web? From my experience, the average user does not understand the web nor AMP, but once the difference is explained, they almost always react negatively to AMP. Of course, there is definitely some bias involved here since it's usually me doing the explaining.
- topicseed 6y agoMost average Joe/Sally's seem to like it, it is predictably fast to load. After all, what's not to enjoy when all you want is to quickly view a page's content without paragraphs jumping around because of late-loading ads... An AMP or regular page is an implementation detail that mostly us care about.