3 ms·
If it's not open-source, then how can you be confident that it doesn't suck? Hobbyists don't tinker with it, people probably don't publish benchmarks of it. Sur
by lmm 6y ago
If it's not open-source, then how can you be confident that it doesn't suck? Hobbyists don't tinker with it, people probably don't publish benchmarks of it. Sure, maybe it works fine, but it might also be awful. So why take the risk when there's an open-source option?
- jodrellblank 6y ago"Ninety per cent of Fortune 500 companies use Azure AD, the sign-in engine for Office 365." - https://azure.microsoft.com/en-gb/services/active-directory/integrate/#features https://azure.microsoft.com/en-gb/services/active-directory/... But you can't know whether it works unless hobbyists tinker with it?? (Even though hobbyists do tinker with Windows)
- lmm 6y agoYep. I've seen lots of terrible software used by Fortune 500 companies - the person making the purchasing decision usually isn't the person actually using it, so the software quality has no impact on whether it gets bought.
- jodrellblank 6y agoI've seen lots of terrible open source software - nobody is purchasing it, and the people who would normally make purchasing decisions aren't involved at all, so the software quality has no impact on whether it gets bought.
- lmm 6y agoSure. But you can find what people say about a given piece of open-source software; generally people will have tinkered with it and kicked the tires a bit and written up their impressions, maybe ran some benchmarks. And maybe you miss out on the occasional gem that way because there's a really good library that just hasn't been touched by anyone for whatever reason, but at least you can avoid picking a lemon. Whereas there are lots of lemons in the proprietary software market, and no real way to distinguish them.
- jodrellblank 6y ago> there are lots of lemons in the proprietary software market, and no real way to distinguish them. You can find what people say about a given piece of proprietary software; generally people will have used it and written up their impressions, maybe ran some benchmarks. Have you honestly never seen a review of a closed source program? Never seen anyone write about their likes or dislikes? Never seen any shareware/try before you buy/free tier software? Never seen anyone use some, decide it was bad, and change to another vendor? Never seen someone try the free version of SQL server or comment about their experiences with IIS or review a new release of Windows? Never seen a computer game review? Or a magazine dedicated to game reviews? Or reviews of Apple app store software?
- lmm 6y ago> Have you honestly never seen a review of a closed source program? Never seen anyone write about their likes or dislikes? Never seen any shareware/try before you buy/free tier software? Never seen anyone use some, decide it was bad, and change to another vendor? Never seen someone try the free version of SQL server or comment about their experiences with IIS or review a new release of Windows? For enterprise software? Pretty much no. You don't tend to get shareware-style free trials, the more common model is a fully functional (and sometimes even open source) free version and then a paid version with additional features. Companies do switch vendors but it's hard to impossible to connect that with the actual user experience. You see case studies but usually published by the vendor themselves; a neutral reviewer doing comparisons is virtually unheard of. And it's pretty common for the licenses to forbid benchmarking or reviews (Oracle famously does). When you're talking about software that only makes sense on the scale of a multi-machine network, who's going to go to the trouble of reviewing it? My experience is that hobbyists sometimes will, but only for the open-source stuff. Back when I worked for a Fortune 500 client we did do full-scale evaluations of proprietary systems, but they were always internal-only. If you're big enough to have your own evaluation department then sure, knock yourself out (this company was also big enough to do things like use their own internal programming language). But for a medium-sized company it's just too risky IME.
- tomc1985 6y agoCall me crazy, but as a hobbyist I tinkered with (pirated) Windows Server, Exchange, and Active Directory installs. I had OWA up and running from my home IP, it synced contacts and email with my phone via some exchange integration, years before gmail. It was actually a lot of fun around the Server 2003 era. And while complex and byzantine, Windows Server was rock solid if you treat it right.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoSaying this w/ extensive experience w/ Windows Server, Linux, and a couple of very old Unix flavors: Anything can be complex and byzantine if the developers put their minds to it.
- jiggawatts 6y agoAre you... joking? First of all, I have decades of experience with Windows, Linux, and BSD. I know they all suck, just in different ways. Don't automatically assume that the only operating system with which you are familiar is magically better. You've just become accustomed to its flaws and warts. It is the devil you know, and other, unfamiliar systems are scary and strange. To you. Not to other people. By the way, the hobbyist tinkering is the main cause of the things I've found to suck in Linux. It's just unprofessional, through and through. It hasn't got the "boring bits" filled out, the bits nobody could be bothered to tinker with because they weren't being paid to. It still(!) struggles with spaces in file name paths. In 2020 it still struggles to consistently handle esoteric new concepts like the backspace key. A case in point is the wailing and gnashing of teeth in the Linux community about systemd. From an external objective perspective, this is absurdly childish. Linux is missing 80% of the basic functionality that MacOS and Windows have had since forever. Since the NT4 days in the 1990 forever. In reaction to the systemd team dragging Linux into this century, people lost their minds. They got so mad they were practically frothing at the mouth. I've seen similarly amateurish, unprofessional, dismissive attitudes everywhere I've turned whenever I hit a problem with Linux. Most recently I dug into the history of why its DNS client is so incredibly bad, and it was just a shitshow of stupid, stupid arguments on various forums that have gone on for decades. Idiots arguing very loudly overruling the people giving good, but humble advice.
- w7 6y ago"80% of the basic functionality" Is this a desktop functionality oriented post or something? Because there are things I find daily that can't be done with Windows Server, but come out of the box on most Linux distributions. Mostly storage, monitoring, or networking related-- aka some of the most important things.
- jiggawatts 6y agoYou mean like Storage Spaces, ReFS, Access Control Lists including rich Claims support, TPM-integrated volume encryption, cluster volume encryption, encrypting file system with user-friendly smart card integration? Or do you mean things like the Windows Management Instrumentation that is object oriented, works locally and remotely, and has over ten thousand counters by default? Or the event log that has had circular binary logs and log forwarding available with no extra software for two decades? Or do you mean how Windows Server has RDMA support so that even simple things like file transfers over SMB3 can run at wire speed on 40 Gbps Ethernet and replace fibre channel at a fraction of the cost? Or is it the native IPv6 support that actually works (unlike, say, MacOS)? Are you talking about the Windows DNS client, which unlike Linux can properly handle an unresponsive primary DNS server? Or the policy-driven IPsec support? The Always On VPN capability maybe? Which of these important things were you referring to?