4 ms·
> With lower capacity hopefully comes lower demand for air travel - this can only be a good thing. Why is it only a good thing? Lower capacity for air travel m
by pdonis 6y ago
> With lower capacity hopefully comes lower demand for air travel - this can only be a good thing.
Why is it only a good thing? Lower capacity for air travel means all kinds of travel that is of value to people can't reasonably take place any more. People have relatives and friends that live too far away to make visiting in person by any other means infeasible. People want to go to see places in person that they can't feasibly get to any other way. People have business reasons to make trips that can't feasibly be made any other way. There was a lot of demand pre-COVID for air travel for a reason. The capacity just vanishing is a loss for many.
- tspike 6y agoI'm guessing because the costs to the consumer for a ticket don't reflect the costs to the world in carbon emissions.
- lsllc 6y agoA good thing for the environment perhaps.
- lmm 6y ago> People have business reasons to make trips that can't feasibly be made any other way. There was a lot of demand pre-COVID for air travel for a reason. Maybe. I think we've seen that a lot of those business trips weren't actually necessary as such, and were more about making an expensive signal of commitment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mr_toad 6y agoThose business trips probably were necessary in the 70’s, before the internet and video conferencing. But in 2019 I think most trips were more about corporate inertia than practical need.
- hkt 6y agoAlso perks. I've had some fun trips to California that I suspect were not entirely necessary - we'd have been fine if we could have just all shifted our working days to overlap for a week or so.
- chriswarbo 6y agoThese things are always a balance between cost and benefit, and the status quo is just a temporary equilibrium based on oil prices, labour costs, environmental policy, technology, safety standards, business models, etc. and should change as those do. I try to avoid getting too anchored to incidental aspects of the present. One way is to turn those questions around: what about the people with relatives and friends that already live too far away to make travel feasible? What about all the places that people already can't feasibly get to? What about all of the business which already doesn't get done due to travel practicalities? There will always be more opportunities to open up by cranking the dial a bit further; but we have to strike a balance somewhere due to the costs. It's a shame that so many opportunities are already blocked by travel costs, but there's no point losing sleep over it. Likewise, if the current costs are too great (e.g. environmentally), then the dial should be turned down a little. Many people would be disadvantaged, but they'd just get added to all those already disadvantaged by the current equilibrium. It's not, in itself, a reason to avoid dialing things down. The things which really matter are: the relative numbers of people affected, whether the budget could be made more equitable or prioritised (e.g. charging frequent flyers more, to keep one-off prices lower), etc.
- pdonis 6y ago> I try to avoid getting too anchored to incidental aspects of the present. Many aspects of the present are not "incidental", they are based on choices that people made in the past in the context of expectations about the future and what options would reasonably be available to them. A sudden drastic change in the actual options available in the present vs. what options people reasonably expected when they made significant choices in the past (like where to live and where to locate businesses) is going to have a drastic impact on people. Yes, a new equilibrium will need to be found and we're not just going to go back to the way things were before, but to say that the drastic change that has happened "can only be a good thing", as the post I originally responded to did, ignores the large negative impact of the change on people who made significant choices in the past that they would not have made if the future they had expected then was the same as our actual present now.
- anonymfus 6y agoKurtis Baute made a good visual illustration about carbon impact of air travel in his recent video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvhXtOps4MM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvhXtOps4MM