3 ms·
It's strange that I've never once heard anyone claim that the weird US phone networks have given Apple an advantage. Imagine if your broadband provider forced
by ZeroGravitas 16y ago
It's strange that I've never once heard anyone claim that the weird US phone networks have given Apple an advantage.
Imagine if your broadband provider forced you to spend at least $600 dollars on a laptop every two years. You could spend a bit more and so get a $1000 dollar laptop for "only" $400 dollars, or you could get a $600 laptop for "free", and laptops below $600 dollars simply wouldn't make sense, and neither would sticking with your current device (note you're only allowed to connect one device at time, two devices need two broadband connections). You'd be throwing away money in that scenario since they'd still charge you the $600 dollars over your contract term and it would make complete sense for you as an individual to upgrade each time to another high-end machine (even though Europeans would be completely baffled by your collective behaviour and your insistence that mid-range Acer and Asus machines are "free" and therefore "worthless" since they buy their computers and broadband connections separately, or at least if bundled they get an appropriate discount for buying less expensive machines).
In that kind of distorted market I can imagine Apple doing quite well, since their competitors would be forced to compete on their mid-to-high-end terms, on their home turf, in a market quite unlike that of other nations.
- ovi256 16y agoYou seem to imply that in some pure, completely free phone market Apple would be priced out. Unfortunately, that market does not exist. So Apple understood the market conditions and adapted to them ? More power to them.
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoA (relatively) free market for phones does exist globally, and Apple's first mover advantage (and the profits and marketshare it brings) is being rapidly diminished in a fairly textbook case of free market competition. I believe Tim Cook has gone on record about these price pressures. But that wasn't my point. My point was that people within the U.S. bubble seem to recognize on some level that they've got a weird market dynamic for smartphones. But they seem to think that this has only helped Android ("because it's free"), and hindered Apple. Which seems a bit odd to me, as outlined in my first post. I think people who are outside the bubble can understand this better since a) Android is doing well outside the bubble too, so we don't need to look for crazy excuses to explain this "anomaly" b) we have a better grasp on the distortions that those in the bubble experience because we have an outside perspective (e.g. Android phones are not actually "free", nor do iPhones cost $200).