7 ms·
Is minimum wage workers affording an average 1-2 bedroom apartment with no other householders a goal we have set? The French minimum wage is 1,521 euro per mont
by rayiner 6y ago
Is minimum wage workers affording an average 1-2 bedroom apartment with no other householders a goal we have set? The French minimum wage is 1,521 euro per month. 30% of that is 456 euros, or about $513. According to the underlying study, the average 1BR in Alabama is $665. Is housing in France, on average, really that much cheaper than Alabama?
I don’t think these abstract targets are very helpful. According to the OECD, the US has some of the most affordable housing in the world: https://read.oecd-ilibrary.org/economics/the-average-oecd-household-has-79-of-disposable-income-left-after-housing-costs_21f178bd-en https://read.oecd-ilibrary.org/economics/the-average-oecd-ho... (showing percentage of disposable income left after housing costs).
Also, the demand for a “federal affordable housing policy” is pretty breathtaking. Look at the list of states that have the least affordable housing: New York, Massachusetts, etc. A federal program would basically mean bureaucrats from these states would be imposing housing policy on the whole country. That sounds like a great idea!
- standardUser 6y agoLook at it from the other direction. Is working 40 hours per week but not being able to afford a 1 or 2 bedroom apartment a goal we want to set? If so, we have achieved it! I think most of us like the idea that if you put in 40 hours of work every week, regardless of the specific job, you are able to afford a basic standard of living.
- rayiner 6y agoYou’re begging the question. Is having your own 1BR apartment a “basic standard of living”? When did we decide that? Is that a goal other developed countries have set and achieved? Those are the pertinent questions, not what ideas “we like.” According to the study, that standard would require a $30-40 minimum wage in places like New York. Is that something any country has done?
- brewdad 6y agoAh yes, the attitude that put a man on the moon. "Nobody else in the world has accomplished this, so why should we even bother trying?"
- eggsmediumrare 6y agoWhy wouldn't we want that? Isn't the point of progress to improve life for everyone?
- ProfessorLayton 6y agoThis is completely subjective. In many countries it's very common to have multiple generations living under one roof all supporting each other.
- yeahAL09 6y agorayiner is an American lawyer with heavy bias to tradition in that context. If America changes too much, all that legal education goes to waste. It’s biologically motivated self selection. “Keep the laws and norms from changing, or my influence!”
- dang 6y agoPersonal attacks aren't allowed and will get you banned here, so please don't. Also, while I have you: could you please stop creating accounts for every few comments you post? We ban accounts that do that. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. You needn't use your real name, of course, but for HN to be a community, users need some identity for other users to relate to. Otherwise we may as well have no usernames and no community, and that would be a different kind of forum. https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix&page=0&query=by:dang%20community%20identity https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...
- erik_seaberg 6y agoHigher wages in an industry are good for workers who make the cut, but bad for everyone else.
- SECProto 6y agoSince local zoning laws effectively rule out boarding houses (or other affordable living spaces) in most of North America, 1BR is essentially the entry level in most jurisdictions.
- worik 6y agoHence minimum wage workers are homeless
- paulryanrogers 6y agoOr forced to share a place with roommates
- sanderjd 6y agoYour argument here seems very circular to me. You ask "when did we decide that?". That implies that there is some discrete point in time in the past when societal decisions are made. But that's not how societies work, not how politics work. The way it works is that we are continuously "deciding" things like this, through conversations like the one here, and articles like the one we're talking about. It doesn't make sense to say, "this article is reaching for abstract targets that we haven't decided on", because there is no decision point in the past like that, we're discussing what we want right now, in this moment, and the article is part of that discussion. You claim that ideas "we like" are not what is pertinent. But that's also not the way societies and politics work. If we as a society decide that this is a good thing to strive for, that "we like" the idea, we can do that. We can decide we want to do that and discuss it and brainstorm ways to achieve it. Looking at what other countries have done is definitely an interesting input in that discussion, but it certainly isn't the only thing that is pertinent. I think you should just say "I am unconvinced that this should be a goal we have as a society". You seem to be trying to appeal to some larger power, some discrete ledger of things we have decided on, but really I think what you're saying is that you are personally skeptical of this, and perhaps that you believe many others in the society are skeptical of it. Which is cool (I may even agree with that, I'm not sure yet), but it would be more clear to just say that.
- rayiner 6y agoNo, the framing of the article is disingenuous. If you want to make an argument that someone working minimum wage should be able to live in a separate 1BR, go ahead and make that argument. But that’s not what the article does. It claims there is a “housing affordability crisis” because minimum wage workers can’t afford an average 1 or 2 bedroom apartment. That isn’t an argument for raising the standard. It acts like we have already decided on that higher standard.
- sanderjd 6y agoAh, see, the way I read the article is that it is saying that they have already decided that this is the standard for a crisis, not that we have decided. Where "they" in this case is the National Low Income Housing Coalition, and perhaps also the author and maybe by implication the editorial voice of CNBC. I don't see an attempt being made to put words in my mouth; I see an author using their own words to make an argument mostly based on a study by another institution. You're right that articles and studies often use terms like "housing crisis" that don't have objective definitions in a way that fits their subjective definition without doing any throat-clearing to call that out. But I don't think there is any real way around that, it seems like you just have to read things with that in mind. Maybe I'm wrong though. Should every article say things like, "there is no objective definition of a housing crisis, but the NLIHC believes this should be considered one". Perhaps they should!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- centimeter 6y agoNot all 40-hour-a-week jobs are valuable enough to support a high adult standard of living. If adults are still doing those jobs, it’s not a problem with the jobs.
- cameronbrown 6y agoThis is the real issue. Imo: there's not enough upwards mobility in jobs because people are retiring later in life. We need to make it cheaper to retire and for workforces to move up the ladder. I know this sounds elitist, but when I worked in a shop, I didn't expect to be able to afford a house.
- pariahHN 6y agoThis is an interesting point I have not contemplated in my musings on the issue so far. Something I should have thought of earlier since my dad came out of retirement and thus is taking up a position that otherwise could have been occupied by the promotion of someone who graduate more recently. Thanks for sharing it.
- hellisothers 6y agoIt’s a long article but if you just skip along and read around the graphs you get a lot of context on this situation. I also found it fascinating when I first stumbled upon it . https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/BosworthBurtlessZhang_retirementinequalitylongevity_012815.pdf https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Boswort...
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoJust musing a bit further, there are multiple ways you could attack this. For instance, you could also encourage people to work shorter hours—we've all become much more productive in the past century, so why are we still working 40 hours a week at minimum?
- cameronbrown 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- DeonPenny 6y agoI don't think most of think this. It doesn't scale. That would mean you could have households of one people with another rent to afford 4 houses. Thats 1.2 billion units of housing just in case people want to live alone. Even if you only do half thats a crazy stat. 600 million units and having to hit that right on the head in terms of the distribution of humans at all time.
- monadic2 6y ago> A federal program would basically mean bureaucrats from these states would be imposing housing policy on the whole country. Funny way to put "providing housing for its own citizens".
- bonestormii_ 6y agoI'm for regulation of the housing industry, but he's not wrong that public housing policy is a shit show. What he is wrong about is that landlords actually prefer it this way, because they prefer subsidies to pricing regulation.
- monadic2 6y agoTo which public housing policy are you referring?
- yeahAL09 6y agoIs expecting minimum wage workers to all live in Alabama a goal we have set? Look what happens when politicians responsibly build post offices and the numerous other programs that made money until political meddling. Look at what happened to workers when taxes were way higher! Omg those stupid politicians!! Is the profiteering of a minority of the species a goal we have set? Is your ideology the goal we should have set? Or is it just automated energy sucking deflection away from ideas that rustle your jimmies wrapped around your limbic system? We share one physics, one planet. Just because you can imagine and emit alternate sounds to someone else doesn’t mean the ideas are feasible or real? Reality comes with some pretty tight constraints. Progressivism away from grandpas political talking points is one of them. Are we less free in some real way given the time wasting mess of our “free market”? Or would it be that your brain is just not used to processing the idea? Are you measuring the impact to society and reality or just chomping at the bit to react? Bureaucrats aren’t going away and already control your life in very intimate ways! Human society has yet to create that magical completely free system or completely gridlock itself to death. Kind of wonder if you’re just shouting at a mirage. It’s just people.
- bonestormii_ 6y agoHaving worked a lot in a rental market with a very active housing subsidy program, I agree that the administration of such programs is an actual nightmare, but you really are missing the point I think. Start with the assumption that people need to be able to afford a place to live, and that a full time job should be able to achieve that. Do you agree? Now, if we both agree that a housing subsidy program is an administrative nightmare, what's left? Simple: Regulating prices on the housing market. A subsidy is a nightmare to administer; is subject to corruption, mis-targeting, abuse, and extreme wait lists; and drains public resources. So why do we do it? Simple: Because the real estate industry has lobbied the government to pursue this as a means to address housing inequality. Rather than being told that the earnings of their investment properties will be capped by regulation, the government is writing a check to make up the difference. So now, after years of waiting, a single mother of two might get a 3/4 of her rent paid by a subsidy. The apartment needs to pass ridiculous inspections which are conducted historically by specialized contractors who benefit from failing due to re-inspection fees, and they will fail an inspection because a screw is missing from a light switch cover, blowing up a lease deal and elongating the timeline for a subsidized move-in by months. It sucks for the residents, and it sucks for the landlord from a administrative/management perspective (mainly dealt with by hired management), but at the end of the day, they have a government-guaranteed rent payment for a greatly inflated rent market. Coronavirus cut your tenant's hours?! No problem! At least 3/4 the rent will be paid, and the margins are still profitable. And we wonder why wealth inequality is growing in the US! This literally inflates the rental market by creating more demand for overpriced housing than exists, by creating a class of people who can afford it only through a majority subsidy. It also encourages investment property purchases by doing so, in turn creating more competition in the buyers market and causing price inflation there as well. This also has the effect of keeping more people renting instead of being able to buy. In conclusion, PEOPLE NEED HOUSING! Real estate industry doesn't need subsidies. Yes,that includes private landlords with investment properties. Someone else's housing or health care shouldn't be an unregulated investment opportunity if we care about the well being of the people.
- prepend 6y ago> Start with the assumption that people need to be able to afford a place to live, and that a full time job should be able to achieve that. Do you agree? For me, it’s the definition of a minimum place to live. When I was young, I had roommates. I don’t think every working person should be able to afford a 1 bedroom apartment. There are multi family dwellings, studios, boarding rooms, etc. If I’m by myself and making minimum wage then I think it’s ok to not be able to get my own one to two bedroom in the city of my choosing. I’m ok with having to live in the burbs and train or drive in. It sucks, but there’s no reason why minimum wage is a permanent condition.
- vharuck 6y ago>Is minimum wage workers affording an average 1-2 bedroom apartment with no other householders a goal we have set? There's a very good chance there are people whose quality of life would be drastically diminished if they had to share an apartment. Off the top of my head, those with embarrassing or inconvenient medical issues, single parents, people who always feel some level of stress around other people (there are a lot of us). When setting floors by policy, we should think of the people who don't fit the norm. If they don't get help from somewhere else, they're screwed.
- rayiner 6y agoDoesn’t it make sense to set the floors based on the typical person, and accommodate other people in personalized ways? For example, the vast majority of low wage workers are not parents. If we want to set a floor for parents, we can have housing subsidies for families with children. Isn’t that better and more efficient?
- scarface74 6y agoWe already have a floor for parents - the EITC. We have the mechanism in place already. Just not the political will to raise it. Historically, the EITC has been supported by both Republican and Democratic administrations.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- flukus 6y ago> Is minimum wage workers affording an average 1-2 bedroom apartment with no other householders a goal we have set? It's not a goal we set but it's one we mostly achieved none the less, depending on your specific area and minimum wage. A blue collar (minimum - low wage) worker used to be able buy a house and raise a family on a single income. People are poorer than they were decades ago, at least where it counts.
- throwaway53457 6y agoThis is likely one of the unintended side effects of 1) women entering the workforce 2) higher retirement age. With double the supply, it meant you could no longer raise a family on a single income, because the money is shared between more people.
- thephyber 6y ago> With double the supply ... In a multivariable equation, you can't only look at one variable and call it a day. How much has demand changed? How much has the population of the USA grown? How many immigrants has the US taken in? How much more efficient is each marginal employee in a blue collar job now compared to then? How well do USA exports compete with other countries? How well does the USD exchange rate compete with the currencies of those other exporting countries? How much have the average work benefits changed over the same period of time? How much has the US cost of living grown? What is the US labor participation rate?
- throwaway53457 6y agoI wasn't looking at a single variable, I was looking at two. You're right of course. The problem is many of those things you're referring to (e.g. cost of living) is directly influenced by said supply. People aren't having families as much, but that means there's now an oversupply of expensive family homes.)
- II2II 6y agoWhere does the article make mention of no other householders? If anything, the article suggests the opposite. It notes that the average minimum wage earner would need to work 97 hours for a two bedroom, and 79 hours for a one bedroom. That reflects two full time minimum wage incomes: a working couple for a one bedroom, and a working couple with children for a two bedroom. It is also worth noting that this is a very privileged position in many cases. If you are a committed couple, are rooming with a close friend or family member, or fit a limited number of other circumstances - this may be acceptable. Otherwise, it is effectively saying that it is okay to expose minimum wage earners at greater risk because, well, they are minimum wage earners.
- black_puppydog 6y agoParis is expensive, but I've rented studio apartments here in Grenoble, France, for about 450eur, yes. Given, Grenoble is nothing of not a small town compared to Paris. But those apartments were also in the very heart of the city, one was directly at the river with a panorama view of the alps. edit since these details matter here: two apartments in question. One was a 1R without, the other a Studio with amazing view. Both were very pleasant, central, and I could have found cheaper had I been willing to not have them that central. /edit So yeah there are much cheaper places than the US. German rents tend to be cheaper still, with higher wages. That all being said, calling out the people at the very bottom for their lavish lifestyles / demands seems a bit disconnected from the economic realities at the moment...
- worik 6y ago"calling out the people at the very bottom for their lavish lifestyles / demands" A room of one's own is a lavish demand? Yes.
- black_puppydog 6y agoI'm sorry if my position didn't come across clearly. My position is that a 1R is by no means lavish. It should be a matter of common decency that someone working full time should feel entitled to be able to afford one, at least for rent.
- worik 6y agochur
- rayiner 6y agoBut what is the average price for a 1BR in Grenoble? Because that’s what the study is looking at, not a cheap price for a studio. In Huntsville you can find a nice studio downtown for $500 or so.
- user5994461 6y agoFor 400-450 you get a studio (think less than 25 sqm 270 sqft ). Typical student accommodation. That's absolutely not what US/UK call a 1 bedroom. A one bedroom is about 600€ a month.
- thephyber 6y agoI'm not opposed to your general points, but there are a few flaws in your data. Those earning minimum wage aren't going to be able to afford "an average" apartment. They will likely only be able to afford a starter apartment which is more likely to cost much less than average and are more likely to live with family members or commute from a more affordable geographic locale. Income in US is not directly comparable to most other OECD countries for multiple reasons. Labor laws (paid vs. unpaid sick days, vacation days, ma/paternity time off, union dues), taxation policies (local, state, federal, employer), health care costs (no nationwide price negotiation), health insurance costs (lots of problems here), school tuition costs (because the demographic highly overlaps with school-aged young adults), lack of public transportation in most geographic regions, etc all add up to costs which are obscured by using the simple "gross income after housing and maintenance" figure.
- einpoklum 6y ago> Is minimum wage workers affording an average 1-2 bedroom apartment with no other householders a goal we have set? Well, it's one of three possible goals: 1. Any worker can afford a roof over his/her head with their wage. 2. Universal public housing. 3. Millions of homeless people. I actually think (2.) is just as important as (1.), but the US isn't very keen on economic activity for public benefit. Then again, it often seems like it's leaning towards (3.) ...
- user5994461 6y agoA one bedroom is around 600€ a month in all the major French cities. The country is very homogeneous with salaries tightly coupled to the minimum wage. Paris might be around 1200€ I think for a similar 1 bedroom but I am not very familiar with Paris. Maybe 1000-1500 depending on commute and location.
- rayiner 6y agoSo 600 euros is more than 30% of the French minimum wage. Is it expected that a minimum wage worker in France can live alone in a 1 bedroom apartment?
- user5994461 6y agoI think it's generally doable and done, except in Paris where you couldn't afford any sort of accommodation at all. There is little left at the end of the money. You're not going to holidays or restaurants any time soon. Hope the car doesn't break or you're in serious troubles. Assuming you were handed a car by your parents because you certainly can't acquire one by yourself (3000 or 4000 upfront!).
- woodandsteel 6y agoThe promise of the free market economy is that the standard of living keeps improving over time, and that includes housing. For probably a majority of the population of the US, that has not been the case for a number of decades.
- rayiner 6y agoI mean that's just not true. With respect to housing, for example: https://www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/houses1.jpg https://www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/houses1.jpg The median new home is double the size of what it was in 1973. In today's new houses, each person has about as much space as the entire solidly middle class 3BR house my four-person family lived in growing up.
- woodandsteel 6y agoOh you have to be kidding. I grew up in the 50's, and things are so much more difficult for young people today. If they are in the upper quarter of society they have to compete so much harder, and if they are below that they are so much less likely to have a good job, like the secure, union factory jobs that were so common. And besides that education has gotten vastly more expensive, and so has housing in much of the country, and also health care. And then there was the great recession of 2007. There are so many young people today who are doing worse than there parents.
- brg 6y agoOne thing always missed in these articles is that 2.7% of the work force makes minimum wage, and that population is not stable (people quickly move out of this baseline). https://www.bls.gov/opub/reports/minimum-wage/2016/home.htm https://www.bls.gov/opub/reports/minimum-wage/2016/home.htm