3 ms·
I'm not sure any major company has either 1) not done business with China or 2) not seriously tried to do business with China. The massive emerging market ther
by ineedasername 6y ago
I'm not sure any major company has either 1) not done business with China or 2) not seriously tried to do business with China.
The massive emerging market there was too much of a $$$ opportunity for them to ignore.
Yes, there's a difference between, say, a fast food chain that tries to get a foot hold in China and a technology company that helps provide tools used to limit rights of free speech etc. However, this is a matter of degree, not kind.
All business with China that helps advance their economy helps to legitimize their regime, and also gives China a significant bit of influence over even companies' non-China businesses. When a company's business is China is so critical to lose that it will subject itself to China's will even outside of China, that company is complicit in the same way, just to a lesser degree, as these tech companies providing more direct support.
- baddox 6y ago> However, this is a matter of degree, not kind. But it sounds like you think that the bad things about China (you specified limiting free speech) differ not in degree but in kind from bad things about other countries. Is that the case?
- ineedasername 6y agoI wasn't at all making a comment on bad things done by other countries. The topic of "bad things that countries do" is a bit too broad to tackle in a single comment.
- baddox 6y agoI meant that presumably you don’t advocate a total refusal of all economic participation with most other countries like you are recommending with China.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Yes, there's a difference between, say, a fast food chain that tries to get a foot hold in China and a technology company that helps provide tools used to limit rights of free speech etc. However, this is a matter of degree, not kind. I disagree. Giving bad people money in exchange for hamburgers is different in kind than giving them the tools they need to continue doing bad things. Hamburgers are a commodity they can get from anyone. Tools are not.
- ineedasername 6y agoIt's not buying hamburgers that's the problem. It's the company itself giving China a bit of control over itself even outside the borders of China. It allows China to impose it's authoritarian actions outside of China.
- Fjolsvith 6y agoThe behavior either way makes me think of dealings with mafia/gangs.
- Aunche 6y agoThe profit made from every Big Mac is money that leaves China and goes into the pocket of a foreign investor. This is infinitely more valuable than McDonalds making a tweet that supports Hong Kong. China knows this, which is why it's so hard for a foreign company to do business there even if you don't consider all the censorship laws.
- godmode2019 6y agoIs believe MacDonald's China its owned by China, they sold all their assets a few years ago because their business model is largely real estate and you can only lease hold land for 99 years in China.
- lacker 6y agoCompanies that are helping China carry out its genocide of the Uighurs, that seems like a difference of kind rather than degree.