4 ms·
A lot of people would have been very surprised if it had failed. The physics wasn't considered a mystery by then. Failure would have been caused by fixable eng
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
A lot of people would have been very surprised if it had failed.
The physics wasn't considered a mystery by then. Failure would have been caused by fixable engineering and design mistakes - or sabotage - not because the idea was unworkable.
There might have been some completely unexpected physics at scale. But given that nuclear reactors were already a thing, that would have been very surprising.
- zabzonk 6y agoTrinity was a plutonium device. Reactors were uranium devices. Nobody was really sure if the plutonium implosion device would work - that's why they did the test; they were very sure that the uranium bullet device, that was used on Hiroshima without testing, would work.
- dllthomas 6y ago> There might have been some completely unexpected physics at scale. But given that nuclear reactors were already a thing, that would have been very surprising. That sort of happened in a later test: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castle_Bravo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castle_Bravo "Castle Bravo's yield was 15 megatons of TNT, 2.5 times the predicted 6.0 megatons, due to unforeseen additional reactions involving lithium-7"
- beervirus 6y agoIf your time tolerance is nanoseconds, the engineering is everything.
- missedthecue 6y agoThat's true with implosion but not gun type
- baud147258 6y agoTrinity was an implosion type bomb, so the required tolerances were tight
- beervirus 6y agoImplosion is what we’re talking about.
- Donthatme 6y agoI am not sure about this. There is a lot of physics other than nuclear going on (rad-hydro,hydrodynamics and atomic physics at HED, etc.)
- hchz 6y agoThis is right on - understanding the equation of state, in extremis, is critical in characterizing the kinetics on the way to disassembly. The metallic phases generated during implosion don't exist in a power reactor.
- mormegil 6y agoBut some people expected that: "The observers set up a betting pool on the results of the test. Edward Teller was the most optimistic, predicting 45 kilotons of TNT (190 TJ). [...] Others were less optimistic. Ramsey chose zero (a complete dud), Robert Oppenheimer chose 0.3 kilotons of TNT (1.3 TJ) [...]" (Wikipedia)
- tempestn 6y agoThat's true, but if you think about today, there are lot of things that are well understood by scientists and yet disputed by many politicians and members of the public. If the Trinity test had failed, it's not inconceivable it would have colored the leadership's perceptions of the feasibility of atomic bombs in general.
- simplicio 6y agoI think the uncertainty had more to do with the implosion mechanism than nuclear physics. The ability to simulate the hydrodynamics of an imploding sphere was obviously pretty limited in 1945, and while Los Alamos devised a series of pretty ingenious experiments to test how symmetrical such implosions could be made, for obvious reasons they had to use mock setups with metals other than Plutonium. So there seems to have been a fair amount of skepticism that such a mechanism could be made to work right up until Trinity.
- tobinfricke 6y ago> A lot of people would have been very surprised if it had failed. How often does a radically new technology work the first time?