7 ms·
> This makes me wonder, what makes DRAM so expensive? Greed does. DRAM makers were antitrust busted at least 7 times on my memory in Taiwan, Korea, and USA.
by baybal2 6y ago
> This makes me wonder, what makes DRAM so expensive?
Greed does. DRAM makers were antitrust busted at least 7 times on my memory in Taiwan, Korea, and USA.
- azinman2 6y agoGreed to me is a funny word here. If illegal antitrust actions are occurring, well that’s obviously bad for the consumer and market, but you say greed as if DRAM makers owe something to the public? They’re a technology business who exist to make money by definition. It’s not a non-profit.
- jeffbee 6y agoThat hasn't been the history of the business. DRAM makers are state-sponsored strategic enterprises which do not act according to rational economic theories.
- black_puppydog 6y agoExactly. Compare that to privately held corporations, which would never think to illegally keep prices up through collaboration, just because they can reasonably expect to get away with it. /s
- rimjongun 6y agoSo it’s either or? Both can’t be right? Geez. Straw man much?
- black_puppydog 6y agowell you can either be state-sponsored or not. if GP is bringing up state-sponsoring as a supposed source of irrationality then yeah I'm assuming that they presume privately held corporations would do better. that being said, I do admit my post was sarcastic, but it also did mention what the problem here is (besides a much broader discussion about captialism) which is that they can rationally expect to get away with this. State-sponsored ones because their interests are the national interest (to an extent) and privately held ones because they're usually able to effectively capture their regulators.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- derefr 6y agoIf that's the only reason, then you'd think companies like Apple with dedicated fab timeshare could cut costs by printing their own RAM chips, rather than buying them. And It's not like DRAM contains any complex IP they'd need to license—if you can lay out a CPU, you can lay out RAM.
- grandinj 6y agoThe IP is mostly in the production process, not the circuit itself. They need to get (relative to logic chips) very low failure rates to turn a profit, which requires very extensive tuning of the manufacturing process.
- psurge 6y agoMy understanding is that DRAM processes are sufficiently different from logic processes that they tend to get dedicated fabs. So then companies like Apple would have to buy fab timeshare from RAM manufacturers that have no incentive (as far as I can see) to let them produce DRAM for less than whatever the bulk pricing is.
- baybal2 6y agoYes
- derefr 6y agoWhat's the reason, then, that anyone with the capital to do so (again, e.g. Apple) doesn't just build a RAM fab, to both get cheap RAM for themselves, and join the cabal selling marked-up RAM to others? Seems like RAM manufacturing is like building a casino: expensive to do, but basically a sure bet.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wtallis 6y agoThe problem is that you need to have $10+B to throw at the problem after you license patents from the incumbents, and even then you'll end up being behind them technologically by the time your fab is up and running, so your marginal costs won't be appreciably better than contracting with the existing manufacturers for their more advanced memory. You could theoretically spend several times more than that to try to get ahead over the course of two or three generations, but for that kind of money you could just as easily secure some very preferential pricing from one or more of the incumbents, thereby ensuring that everyone else trying to put a lot of RAM into a PC has to pay more. The most viable path to establishing a new leading-edge competitor in this space is for a government to throw lots of money at the problem, knowing that it'll be years at best before it produces anything competitive, but having the advantage of being able to more or less ignore IP issues and having a potential demand far higher than any one memory customer can produce on its own. China is doing this for the NAND market, too.
- lend000 6y agoThe processes to form NAND and DRAM are completely different. DRAM relies on creating non-leaking capacitors which are highly difficult to manufacture at such a small scale. NAND benefits from innovations in the CPU lithography space since it's essentially all transistor based. Why would you expect them to have the same price, unless you knew nothing about the technology? Also, there are plenty of distinct competitors in the DRAM space. Do you have a source suggesting Micron and Samsung are engaging in price fixing together?
- kasabali 6y ago"Plenty" of distinct being Samsung, Micron and Hynix. They are not necessarily price fixing illegally. It's just that they all keep their production and capacity expansions closely in check to not ever let prices down. That and in rare cases when prices are down due to unexpected decline in shipments they're all very swift to shift wafers to produce something else. Feel free to dig DRAMeXchange reports for for details.
- amINeolib 6y agoSamsung is one of the worst companies. Among the BP, AT&T, Comcast, and Apple tier evils. I'm not sure how they have survived bad press, but Samsung is not a good company.
- wtallis 6y ago> NAND benefits from innovations in the CPU lithography space since it's essentially all transistor based. It's really not, especially in the 3D NAND flash era where only one manufacturer is still using a floating gate cell. It's so thoroughly not transistor based that the Chinese upstart's claim to fame is that they fabricate the transistors on an entirely different wafer from the memory cells, and glue them together later. It's best to think of NAND, DRAM and logic as three separate categories that each require a very different mix of tools in the fab, especially on the back-end. (But you won't be finding EUV or quad-patterning in the front-end of a NAND fab, either.)
- vitus 6y agoIf the difficulty of DRAM is in creating capacitors at that size, why haven't we seen a shift toward SRAM (6T, for instance), which is purely transistor-based? Sure, you have to sacrifice more transistors for the same capacity, but newer processes can fit more on the chip, right? I recall from computer architecture classes that the benefit of DRAM is the ability to use fewer transistors, but if transistors are cheap... (I'm sure I'm missing something here. Power consumption / heat generation? I also never really understood why SRAM continues to be so expensive, when it seems like it would obviously benefit from smaller processes.)
- markandrewj 6y agoThis is why even though memory was becoming dirt cheap, prices started to spike in the last few years. There are also less manufactures now as a result of buyouts and mergers.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoAdd the European Union, Infineon. [0] https://www.finanznachrichten.de/nachrichten-2010-05/16940239-eu-kommission-verhaengt-millionenstrafe-gegen-infineon-016.htm https://www.finanznachrichten.de/nachrichten-2010-05/1694023...