5 ms·
I wonder if you could give them access to a custom subdomain of a test site and tell them to build a web app, anything they want, and upload it. Give a suitabl
by SkyMarshal 16y ago
I wonder if you could give them access to a custom subdomain of a test site and tell them to build a web app, anything they want, and upload it. Give a suitable time limit, a day to a week, depending on how much you want to see and whether they already are a full-time employee or student. Then screen based on what people came up with.
That's a bit more involved than the lighter-weight solution in the same vein - remote coding tests facilitated by a collaborative website. But it's something I haven't heard of yet.
- roel_v 16y agoRight, that's because no sane prospect (or rather, a prospect you'd want to hire) would go along with it. A reasonably competent developer has several options to choose from - it's just not rational to spend 10+ hours on each job opening; you wouldn't be able to coordinate and assess 5 or so offers in a reasonable time (when looking for a new job, people will apply at various places, compare the offers and take the best one). Most competent people would scoff at a suggestion like this, and I suspect that competent employers know it.
- haploid 16y agoWe did this for our most recent front-end hire, actually. We gave him a two-day project to complete for us, and compensated him with what we thought to be a fair stipend for his time. He completed the project, we hired him, he cleaned up the project, and we actually put it into production a week after his hiring date. Everything worked out fine, and the developer in question is quite competent, sane, and rational.
- mcherm 16y agoAs a SCREENING mechanism 10 hours might be too much for the candidate to spend. But once past the initial screening, if there is serious consideration of an actual job offer, it is quite reasonable. The company will spend a good deal more than that on every candidate brought in for interviews (if you add up the time of everyone at the company). If the applicant is considering tens of different offers then they're Doing It Wrong(TM) -- they should pick the 4 best and choose amongst those. If they're considering 4 offers and can't spend 10 hrs on each, then why on earth not?
- EarthLaunch 16y agoAsking someone to spend 10 unpaid hours on a test is a great filter - for developers to see that a company doesn't value their time.
- roel_v 16y agoBecause it's 40 hours wasted. 40 hours = one full working week = for (I think) the type of professional we're talking about $2000. I guess we can differ in opinion on what is 'reasonable' but I say that requiring what you're proposing is too much for me personally to take any such employer serious. (on the part of the 'past initial screening', the employee can't know or verify this. If there are 50 applicants, and there are 15 selected in the 'initial screening', is it reasonable to ask for 150 hours of unpaid labor from these people? I posit it's not.)
- InclinedPlane 16y ago$2k to find a good hire is nothing. Signing bonuses, referral bonuses, and interview related expenses (air travel, taxis, hotels) are often on that scale or larger. Also, your numbers are way off the mark, you're not going to bring in 15 people for such an interview, you'd be extraordinarily lucky if you even managed to have 15 people that looked good enough to go that far, but even if you did you'd screen it down to a lower number to make it more feasible.
- roel_v 16y ago
- schammy 16y agoHmm, not a bad idea. My company is going to be hiring soon, I'm thinking about doing something like this. It would be relevant to our service though, not just a random web app. e.g., building something on top of our API. Thanks for the idea!