2 ms·
To whatever degree a mental health issue is treatable with drugs, it genuinely is a medical issue. But that's not the only element of actual insanity. Real ins
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
To whatever degree a mental health issue is treatable with drugs, it genuinely is a medical issue.
But that's not the only element of actual insanity. Real insanity almost always involves a sick social fabric as well that lies to you about critical information, often blaming you for problems over which you have no real control.
They know that schizophrenics often get better with in patient treatment, then go home to their screwed up families and get worse again.
My sister took graduate courses in psychology for a time. She once said to me "We clearly don't have the genes for schizophrenia in the family or someone would have it because the family would have driven them crazy by now." Dad fought in two wars. Mom grew up in a war zone. These were haunted people who could be rather difficult to deal with.
I can understand people wanting to make this distinction "that I just need a pill, it's not like I'm crazy." People who are seriously crazy aren't typically fixable with just a pill. It's more complicated than that and our current system isn't really all that effective at bringing people back once they've gone nuts.
This is part of why I object to the "homeless people are all junkies and crazies" meme: it actively helps make vulnerable people crazy. It actively blames them for things they don't control and denies the existence of systemic issues to the faces of the victims who have such a low social status and are so openly disrespected that they aren't in a good position to argue with it. They are expected to kowtow and agree with everyone hanging their crap on them.
So it actively helps drive homeless people insane and makes it a self fulfilling prophecy. It deepens the problem and is actively abusive of our most vulnerable citizens.
- wolfram74 6y agoMany good points, but to clarify, you're arguing that being treatable is merely an obvious indication that it's a medical issue, but not the only indication? Lots of things in non-mental health fields are acknowledge to be medical problems but also remain untreatable.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI'm really tired and I'm not sure I understand what you are saying. I did leave a reply earlier, then removed it. I have no idea if you saw that. I think mental health issues are complex. To whatever degree a pill actually helps, it's legitimate to view it as medical. I have a lot of medical issues and I deal a lot with somatopsychic side effects. It's a somewhat obscure word meaning you get genuine mental health effects as a side effect of actual medical issues. I don't use drugs to treat my issues. I mostly treat them nutritionally and there is research into how diet impacts brain chemistry and so forth. I have seen research indicating that nutritional supplements have a better track of treating certain issues than the prescription medication typically used. I know a lot about the topic and related topics. I spent a few years in therapy for abuse endured as a child. I've done a lot reading and I've thought carefully about how to handle certain things in my life for which there aren't supposed to be any good solutions. Social fabric and the mental models that it reinforces is another huge element of mental health. My medical issues don't turn into psychiatric issues in part because my two adult sons still live with me and they are abundantly familiar with the somatopsychic issues I am prone to and how to address them. So they do a lot of things that mitigate the issue when I am angsty or depressed or suicidal or whatever. They don't make those things worse by how they respond to them. So I know from firsthand experience that how people around you response to mental health incidents can magnify or minimize them and it is my observation that most people magnify such problems. They take a lurid interest in the issue. They feel a desire to act like your "savior," thereby actively painting you as more screwed up than you are. Etc. ad nauseum. So I'm not really sure how to engage your comment because I don't think I really understand it and I didn't like the reply I left earlier and I may end up not liking this one either, but I also wasn't comfortable just leaving no response. :/
- heavyset_go 6y ago> This is part of why I object to the "homeless people are all junkies and crazies" meme: it actively helps make vulnerable people crazy. It actively blames them for things they don't control and denies the existence of systemic issues to the faces of the victims who have such a low social status and are so openly disrespected that they aren't in a good position to argue with it. They are expected to kowtow and agree with everyone hanging their crap on them. Agree with your insights. To further this point, people who would be deemed to be suffering from schizophrenia in our culture often have worse outcomes than people with similar symptoms in cultures that accept and integrate their different experiences. There's research done on this topic, and this article touches upon some of it[1]: > Stanford anthropologist Tanya Luhrmann found that voice-hearing experiences of people with serious psychotic disorders are shaped by local culture – in the United States, the voices are harsh and threatening; in Africa and India, they are more benign and playful. This may have clinical implications for how to treat people with schizophrenia, she suggests. [1] https://news.stanford.edu/2014/07/16/voices-culture-luhrmann-071614/ https://news.stanford.edu/2014/07/16/voices-culture-luhrmann...
- Dahoon 6y ago>My sister took graduate courses in psychology for a time. She once said to me "We clearly don't have the genes for schizophrenia in the family or someone would have it because the family would have driven them crazy by now." Hogwash! You cannot "drive someone schizophrenic" no matter if they have it in their genes or not. I can't even begin to try and correct this. It's like saying "dad is such a jerk that he drove me to become blonde instead of brunette!"