4 ms·
>but in reality I think the majority of people have better things to do than call on strangers to be fired. But if the majority of people are forced to behave
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
>but in reality I think the majority of people have better things to do than call on strangers to be fired.
But if the majority of people are forced to behave super conservatively in order to hedge against cancel culture does it really matter how small that vocal minority really is?
I see the phenomenon to be similiar to people being worried about frivolous lawsuits or being worried about Karen calling the police because their kids are playing outside unsupervised. These events are rare but fear of them shapes all of society's behavior in a bad way.
- Ekaros 6y agoEven more worryingly the behaviour deemed acceptable seems to be sliding window. So in a few years you can't even be sure any more what is acceptable to people calling for firings and what isn't. Also all past transgressions will count at any later time. So something said today what might be fine is not fine in a few years. And someone might just dig up this thing and rally up lynch mob to act upon it. There has been already cases of this happening. I do really see that some protections are needed. Either by preventing companies taking actions or making the people calling for losing job liable for damages.
- paulgb 6y agoRight, the problem is that a small mob of people can have outsized control by putting pressure on individual employees. To that employee, it doesn't matter how big the mob is. But in terms of ending cancel culture, if a small mob is all it takes, how effective can anything but employment law be? People calling on someone to be fired, after all, have free speech rights themselves; the best the law can do is limit the consequences of that speech.
- pjc50 6y ago> People calling on someone to be fired, after all, have free speech rights themselves Somehow the "everything is free speech and nobody should ever be censored" arguers forget this.
- loopz 6y agoFree speech is not a positive in isolation, but need to be channeled constructively according to democratic principles. Most people are not educated to wield that power.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anthonygd 6y agoDid you just say most people are not educated enough to have free speech?
- scruple 6y agoWhat a wild ride we're on.
- loopz 6y agoYes indeed. Of the kind social media optimize on, most people are NOT educated enough for, or rather, society have not enough controls for; fringe outrage growing into trends and mob. Beware empty belief in general principles.
- perfunctory 6y ago> most people are NOT educated enough for That was a rather fringe outrageous thing to say.
- loopz 6y agoIndeed. So will you protect it, or will you lie? Let me clarify: While people may be educated enough to cast votes how many beans is in the jar, or what cause to support in the moment, they are mostly not equipped to be jury and judge of mob rule, or am I wrong?
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago