4 ms·
> They did not seem to research at all how to actually fund it And this is really the most profound part. There isn't an argument to be made against "if people
by roenxi 6y ago
> They did not seem to research at all how to actually fund it
And this is really the most profound part. There isn't an argument to be made against "if people have more money to buy stuff they will be better off". Nobody can argue against that, it is true.
The _entire_ case against that sort of social spending is "but we need normal people to create more than they consume or the resources won't be available" and "this isn't fair on the people who have to support them" argued at varying levels of complexity and indirection.
If you ignore the negative outcomes then any plan is a good plan and only has positive outcomes. Duh.
- lukevp 6y agoI disagree, it’s not the fairness, or the overproduction, but the best overall benefit to society given the money spent. Social programs that already exist are a progressive tax that penalizes healthy, working people more than those who are receiving the benefit. Examples: unemployment, Medicaid, WIC, Saver’s Credit.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- danaris 6y agoThe level of productivity per capita in the economy today is vastly more than enough to supply our entire population with only a fraction working. There's also plenty of information indicating that if given the choice, most people actually want to work...they just don't want to be working shit jobs for shit pay for shit bosses.
- Ericson2314 6y agoAmen, how many times to we need to tell people, look production and consumption first, and then think about finance? I'm not saying finance is all bad, I'm saying when the financial situation is harder to understand than the so-called "real economy"...don't!
- DonaldFisk 6y agoThe aim of UBI is not to make people better off, but to ensure that everyone has enough money to live on. It's intended to replace means-tested social security. With UBI, nobody falls through the safety net and ends up with nothing to live on; you don't need an army of people assessing claimants' financial circumstances; and when someone finds a low-paid or part-time job they still keep their UBI, so there's no disincentive to work. If you argue it's unfair that people pay for UBI, how is that different from arguing that it's unfair that people pay for means-tested social security (or poor people's medical bills)?
- notahacker 6y ago> If you argue it's unfair that people pay for UBI, how is that different from arguing that it's unfair that people pay for means-tested social security (or poor people's medical bills)? There's a big difference between a welfare state designed as a form of social insurance to protect people from adverse circumstances and old age, and one designed on the assumption that those who want to work owe those who don't a living, and that the only circumstance that should affect how much people receive is whether they have the right citizenship. Aside from the fundamental ethical rationale changing from contribution based social insurance to citizenship based entitlement, UBI would also represent a much larger bill, and a lower payout to the neediest.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoLots of loaded words in there, and not really fairly. Nobody 'owes' anybody a living. The situation is, we can give most folks a living, without everyone working. And those that continue to work, of course are better off because they earn money for that. No unfairness at all. I think its the old Protestant work ethic, this attitude of "folks not working are immoral". We have to get past this, to make UBI a thing.
- notahacker 6y ago> Nobody 'owes' anybody a living The literal purpose of UBI is to ensure that taxpayers do owe each citizen a fixed amount set at an average living. Making that a social obligation based on birthright rather than a potential future entitlement based on need is how it's different from social insurance schemes. The assumption if you're able to work and not interested in looking for it you probably don't need the money as much as other people certainly isn't what's wrong with current welfare states. You don't have to believe that "folks not working are immoral" to believe that helping those fortunate enough to be able to choose not to work at the expense of those that aren't [whether by reduced benefits or higher taxes] isn't what welfare states were for.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoFor many, many things its not really a questions of 'normal people creating" resources. Because most goods are not made by people on assembly lines any more. That's pretty much a tiny fraction. Automation means, only the Engineers and Maintenance people need report to work to keep the goods flowing. Its been happening for 20 years, and accelerating. The UBI may not be quite ready to deploy, but its coming. If we try it too soon, then some goods will indeed become scarcer and thus more expensive. But many things may continue just as they are. We want to make sure that's enough to keep everyone healthy and fed.