4 ms·
As a EU citizen I'm glad about the decision, I don't have any confidence any more that data stored in the US is secure and that the US can be depended upon. Al
by Barrin92 6y ago
As a EU citizen I'm glad about the decision, I don't have any confidence any more that data stored in the US is secure and that the US can be depended upon.
Also important to point out how much of this goes back to Max Schrems activism over the years and noyb (https://noyb.eu/en https://noyb.eu/en). This is a huge win achieved with relatively few resources. Staying engaged is worth it.
- Frost1x 6y agoAs a US citizen, I'm personally glad to see other nations push back against data privacy exploitation by US businesses on the general public. It's evident our own (US) government will do very little to curb those business's overreach. I hope to see more disincentives put forth against these practices in markets our businesses haven't completely supplanted government oversight. Hopefully, that will result in shifts of practices in the US markets as well, though it's certainly not guaranteed.
- nojvek 6y agoChina is looked down for its draconian surveillance. However US is just another side of the same coin. Our big Tech FAANG loves gobbling up everything they can get their hands upon in the name of training AIs that shove more personalized creepy ads.
- jjcon 6y ago> China is looked down for its draconian surveillance. However US is just another side of the same coin. This is not the case - almost all major countries have surveillance agencies. It’s not the fact that China has surveilance that is looked down upon, it’s the lack of checks and balances. Most democratic countries have surveillance to ensure national security interests and they have strict checks and balances to minimize abuse and ensure that intel is used only for national security reasons. China’s surveillance has no such checks and balances and does little to prevent abuse and that is worth criticizing. Perhaps this may change someday but the current party does not seem to be heading in that direction.
- jjcon 6y agoSince many major EU countries share their classified intelligence and surveillance systems with the US (and the reverse) this seems more like political speech than reality. The real reason is to preserve what’s left of tech in the EU but that doesn’t exactly sound as good. Almost all major countries have surveillance programs. They are perhaps necessary to preserve national security. The hope of democratic countries is to have enough checks and balances on those powers to keep them limited to national security interests and to prevent abuse.
- karmakaze 6y agoI was thinking the same thing. It seems that we have passed 'peak globalization' and we're seeking a sweet spot that balances concerns. This could be a good thing.
- M2Ys4U 6y agoThis is one area where you have to separate the EU from its constituent member states. The EU's treaties explicitly reserve national security for the member states themselves (except for where there is unanimity or opt-in in specific areas). As such, in most cases, the Commission and Parliament can't legislate to bring MS' own intelligence services under control. To change the situation the treaties would have to be changed (which is a can of worms in itself) and all 27 members would have to agree to the changes (one or two would require a referendum).
- norenh 6y agoThere is a difference between sharing information (where you control what is shared) and letting the other party have all the information and look at it by their own. The fact that EU shares intelligence with US is less of a problem as long as EU citizens have a somewhat confidence in their government and security services. It is a big difference from letting US process all private information about the EU citizens and by that enable US to rummage around as they wish without having to obey laws or regulations in EU.
- jjcon 6y agoI don’t think you understand - the systems themselves are shared. This isn’t ‘let’s decide to let X country know Y’. If it is on the eyes network (and tons of things are) everyone gets it per the multi country agreement.