5 ms·
I worked on fintech projects in Europe, with German banks as our main clients. Their requirements went as far as refusing any service that would have their supp
by dgellow 6y ago
I worked on fintech projects in Europe, with German banks as our main clients. Their requirements went as far as refusing any service that would have their support teams (or part of it) located in the US. It was quite challenging to fulfill their demands, and increased the development and maintenance cost by A LOT, but definitely possible.
And once you have a working system and solutions in place that becomes a quite good sale argument.
And yes, the EU is really lacking providers that can follow those requirements. At some point Microsoft had a German cloud completely distinct from their other offering and managed by Telekom, but they stopped a few years ago (and it wasn't really in a production ready state IMHO...).
- nix23 6y ago>I worked on fintech projects in Europe I don't see the problem, buy HP Enterprise Hardware (Support is based in Czech Republic), install Suse for example (but not RedHat), ask a Data-center of your wish, place your Hardware there make your own 'cloud'...profit?
- Sebb767 6y agoI don't know how much access they have, but SUSE has quite a few people working from the US.
- nix23 6y agoYes but HQ is in Nürnberg Germany, and so is the DPO: https://www.suse.com/de-de/company/legal/ https://www.suse.com/de-de/company/legal/ Its not about where some people work, it's what they do under witch legality, so a US citizen working in Germany or for German Customers "could" be a problem.
- Sebb767 6y agoThanks for the clarification!
- raverbashing 6y ago> so a US citizen working in Germany or for German Customers "could" be a problem. That's usually fine (related to the "in Germany" part). I'd say you'll only have an issue if you're doing something really high up the government (same as for example SpaceX - which cannot hire non-citizens)
- dgellow 6y agoAs I said, it’s definitely possible. We did create and maintain our own clusters. That’s way more expensive and time consuming than using existing offering from public clouds, and you are in your own in case of issues. Your competitors who don’t have that kind of requirements can build and iterate on their products way faster.
- terom 6y agoThis. Worst-case you end up being forced to use some terribly implemented private cloud solution which ends up being even more expensive and time consuming than deploying your own hardware.
- smartbit 6y agok8s to the rescue ;-)
- dgellow 6y agoI don’t know if you’re joking or not, in the case of those fintech projects I’ve been part of a migration to k8s. That was already in progress 3 years ago when I joined the company, and it wasn’t completed when I left beginning of this year. Managing your own k8s in production isn’t a simple task at all :(
- nix23 6y agoThat is true, i was asked to implement k8s in 6 month, they said so i have plenty of time to find all problem (i try'd really hard not to start laughing)
- nix23 6y ago>Worst-case Then implement it very well, you know like you should do it with the base when you build a House.
- nix23 6y ago>That’s way more expensive I had the pure opposite compared to AWS, with own Cloud we safe d around 80% expenses, calculated with additional manpower about 35%...but still 35% is really something.
- oblio 6y agoAnd if they want to keep data completely out of US Gov hands, as some clients do, it's almost impossible due to the Patriot and Cloud acts.
- ianhorn 6y agoI'd be surprised and saddened if it were legal for a company to offer a contract that they couldn't legally commit to, like saying they'd keep the data out of the U.S. but also give it to the U.S. gov if asked. I guess the legality of offering a contract that they can't commit to is a local legal question, but I'd hope that it's an uncommon thing to allow.
- henryfjordan 6y agoIn the US a contract is voidable if it would be illegal to carry it out, and it might open you up to liability if you knew that at the time of signing, but it's not a crime.
- ianhorn 6y agoWhat do you mean "carry it out?"
- thaumasiotes 6y agohttps://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/carry%20out https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/carry%20out Verbal sense 1/2: > to bring to a successful issue : complete, accomplish > carried out the assignment > to put into execution > carry out a plan
- henryfjordan 6y agoSorry, "perform" would be the legal term. Basically if the contract says "Alice will pay Bob $10 to kill Charlie", then obviously that would be illegal so the contract is void.
- toyg 6y ago
- esperent 6y agoSounds like a golden opportunity for someone to set up an EU company that is EU law compliant and start marketing themselves to banks and bodies that need this.
- thu2111 6y agoProblem is banks and similar institutions that "need" this don't really believe they need it, and see such rulings as more anti-American BS. So they find ways to comply that are absurdly minimal, like using Azure datacenters that are only in the EU. This achieves nothing, it's all still a software stack written in the USA, but it lets them tick the box that says "data resident in <European jurisdiction>". There are ways to run operations in a way that comply with the spirit of these rulings. Hetzner, OVH and other cheap mini-clouds are EU based and have only EU datacenters. Guess where banks want to go? "The cloud" because "the cloud" is "the future" and they institutionally suck at running IT departments of any kind. So they ignore those offerings and find workarounds that let them outsource it all to the Americans who for various reasons just seem culturally better at making software companies. The other problem that discourages people making EU compliant companies is the term is meaningless. EU is famous for rather weak rule of law. The courts have a history of "discovering" entirely new laws in vaguely written rights or regulations, like the famous right to be forgotten that caused and still causes endless operational pain. Not a law written by any lawmaker, not even the unelected opaquely appointed bureaucrats that write laws in the EU. A law literally invented in the courts themselves. Because these laws are effectively invented by the courts or by a quasi-government that doesn't really have its own police forces or much of an enforcement infrastructure, this means many EU regulations aren't really enforced. Compliance is kind of on the honour system. So if you're selling compliance, but it costs a lot more than a US based solution that basically ignores these rules whilst claiming they don't, then you'll lose out to your competitors. The final problem is, again, all this stuff is just legal posturing. The EU has a long history of having intelligence agencies just as aggressive as the NSA, and cutting deals with the USA to get access to US intelligence in return for data (see the SWIFT transfer programme). The EU and its fans like to claim there's some sort of deep cultural difference between Europe and America with regards to privacy, but when you strip away the press releases and look at the actions these countries/EU really make, there's virtually no difference. This is another reason why banks and other firms don't take it too seriously at their core.