3 ms·
The US constitution restricts acts of the federal government to enumerated powers. A lot of stuff gets justified under an expansive interpretation of regulating
by toast0 6y ago
The US constitution restricts acts of the federal government to enumerated powers. A lot of stuff gets justified under an expansive interpretation of regulating interstate commerce, but I'm not sure how a register of citizens qualifies. Certainly, you could find legal scholars who would tell you it's allowed and those who would tell you it's not.
There's a fair amount of resistance to government information gathering, especially by the federal government. There's a bigger question of records quality. There are a lot of citizens who have no records of their birth --- either it wasn't recorded, or the records were lost, or the details you would need to find the records aren't available. Anyone contemplating reconciling all those edge cases is going to simply give up.
- wang_li 6y agoCitizenship and the rights and duties of citizens are all over the constitution. It would be quite the surprise to find out the Federal Government can't keep a list of who is a citizen. I mean we already have social security numbers for a small, universal pension. We have the selective service which gets half the people. We have passports for citizens and visas for non-citizens. We have the REAL ID Act. The country really needs a government that has the balls to enforce the laws as they are written or change them to what they want to enforce. The idea that the effective law is predicated upon the whims of prosecutorial discretion is bullshit.
- syshum 6y agoOhh I am sure the can shoe horn it in under the Commerce Clause along with a little spice of Census
- jhayward 6y agoArticle I, Section 2 of the constitution requires the government to conduct a decennial census, and empowers congress to make such law as it may direct to implement it. One could easily see a national identity system to be justified as part of the census. I'm sure there are other articles that could also be used to justify one. The reluctance around a national identifier and system is purely policy, not lack of constitutional authority.