2 ms·
> we had a huge ordeal converting our 32-bit space weather model to 64-bit because the change in precision changed our results, so we couldn't publish (in good
by lmm 6y ago
> we had a huge ordeal converting our 32-bit space weather model to 64-bit because the change in precision changed our results, so we couldn't publish (in good conscious) without making sure the results weren't within a good margin of error.
Had you done some kind of external validation of the original results? If not, surely the new results are just as valid to publish as the original ones - any bugs are as much or more likely to be in the 32-bit than the 64-bit version.
- codezero 6y agoYep. Our model was run by other organizations and incorporated into amalgamated models that had further downstream error bars that they needed. Not that our model contributed much but we were one tiny part of the early warning system for solar flares for satellites and astronauts. We admittedly weren’t super formal about the transition but wanted to make sure the differences wouldn’t be meaningful or propagate into other models we contributed to. Also fwiw, we had no control or say over how others ran our model so they could have easily done their own 64 bit build of our code but I think it’s unlikely.