5 ms·
While this is a good measure, what does it mean to the decentralization promise of Bitcoin?
by mrtksn 6y ago
While this is a good measure, what does it mean to the decentralization promise of Bitcoin?
- drexlspivey 6y agoIt means dont keep your money at exchanges if you want to control them
- celticninja 6y agoAlso protects the stupid. You can still send this address BTC. You just need to withdraw it to your own wallet first. Which buys the user time in which to discover it's a scam
- seibelj 6y agoPeople who use exchanges are traders (retail or professional) and hodlers who don't want to deal with the intricacies of managing 100+ coins on 50+ blockchain networks. The decentralization of cryptocurrencies is not an all-or-nothing proposition - users can choose the level of decentralization they would like based on their preferences. What I like most about decentralization is that anyone in the world can create a new crypto business on the blockchain rails, integrate with everyone else, and attract users. Of course there are real-world repercussions if your physical entity is in a locale with laws that you violate, but it is orders of magnitude easier to start a crypto exchange than a traditional bank.
- cortesoft 6y agoWon't this end up like email, though? Sure, anyone can set up their own business... however, 90% of people will be on a few large providers, and those providers will end up blocking transactions coming from unknown new providers (to prevent scams). Decentralization doesn't stop consolidation.
- seibelj 6y agoIt is much easier to set up your own cryptocurrency wallet than it is to set up your own trusted email server. Your metaphor is similar but off by a large amount. The major difference is that blockchain deals primarily with money, so email spam (useless worthless messages) is inherently less worthy of sending because doing so actually pays me, in addition to the fees you pay the network.
- Klinky 6y agoIt's not that easy to setup your own wallet. Most require you to download the entire blockchain if you want to be completely independent of a third-party.
- boring_twenties 6y agoWhat's not easy about downloading the blockchain? All you need is to have enough free space, press the button, and wait a while.
- Klinky 6y agoBitcoin is around 270GB. Monero is around 64GB. These aren't trivial downloads, and then you'll need to leave the wallet running to stay in sync or you'll have lengthy waits while it catches up the next time you run. Most people can open a credit card or bank account in 30 minutes or less. Waiting a week for a blockchain to download is a non-starter for most.
- boring_twenties 6y agoActually, it's over 300GB for Bitcoin and almost 85GB for Monero today. Regardless of that, I recently synced Monero from scratch in 3 hours, over a 802.11n network that never seems to do better than ~75Mbps. We can extrapolate that Bitcoin would be done in something like 9.5 hours. So I don't know where you got a week from. If you still don't like that, you can always use a remote node, in which case you can begin using a new account literally immediately, even better than your 30 minutes at a bank. IMHO that is a perfectly fine tradeoff for a new user who doesn't want to commit to syncing the blockchain. Nevertheless, when I deal with new, non-technical users in the Monero community, I find that they almost always prefer to run their own fully synced node, even though they understand the tradeoff (i.e., that using a remote node is probably fine). I even had a guy that has no computer, phone only, looking for help on setting up a full node on his phone. Anecdotal perhaps, but it certainly makes me skeptical of the claim that blockchain size is a big hurdle for many people at all. Oh yeah, and just for completeness: you can prune the blockchain with both Bitcoin and Monero if storage space is a concern, reducing it by something like 70%.
- Sebb767 6y agoSure, but even with E-Mail there are a lot of smaller service providers. It's not _ideal_, yes, but the situation is at least a tad better and one failing company will not destroy the whole ecosystem.
- H8crilA 6y agoKinda similar to like under a gold standard you don't actually pay with gold. You can, but most people just use centralised "wrappers" around gold in the form of bank notes.
- IncRnd 6y agoI don't know of any countries that are still on a gold standard.
- H8crilA 6y agoNeither do I
- ta17711771 6y agoThere is no gold anymore, mate.
- H8crilA 6y agoAny gold dealer begs to differ.
- mirimir 6y agoWell, it's not there's no physical gold, but there's still a shortage. So it's pretty easy to get spot price, even from a local shop. And if you have substantial amounts to sell, you may get spot price plus several percent. Also, I've read that silver is hot now, given the likely surge in the silver/gold ratio.
- mlindner 6y agoJust because you can stuff dollars under your bedsheets doesn't mean you can't also use a bank.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lostmsu 6y agoIn this case you could just create a separate wallet and send BTC through it. Sounds like Poloniex does its job better than your own wallet here.
- baby 6y agoIt means that to block these funds every single recipients must block the address.