5 ms·
> If they want to reform tax law, then it should be forward facing, not trying to reverse previous established policies. The EU argument was that Ireland's "pr
by throw0101a 6y ago
> If they want to reform tax law, then it should be forward facing, not trying to reverse previous established policies.
The EU argument was that Ireland's "previous established policies" were against EU treaty, and so the (alleged) special deal that IE gave Apple should be considered annulled since it was invalid from the day it was signed.
> On this basis, the Commission concluded that the tax rulings issued by Ireland endorsed an artificial allocation of Apple Sales International and Apple Operations Europe's sales profits to their "head offices", where they were not taxed. As a result, the tax rulings enabled Apple to pay substantially less tax than other companies, which is illegal under EU state aid rules.
> This decision does not call into question Ireland's general tax system or its corporate tax rate.
* https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_16_2923 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_16_...
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EU_illegal_State_aid_case_against_Apple_in_Ireland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EU_illegal_State_aid_case_agai...
- rplnt 6y ago> it was invalid from the day it was signed Shouldn't then Ireland pay it (or act as if it was paid, and paid whatever it would have paid from it to the EU budget).
- josefx 6y ago> or act as if it was paid, and paid whatever it would have paid from it to the EU budget Yeah, lets treat this as a fine and fine them $1 for every million it cost the other EU members. Lessons learned: you can get away with everything if you are just bold enough. By agreements they signed they are supposed to collect the taxes in a fair manner, so requiring them to collect the taxes they didn't seems to be the least they can be required to do. That would also have the side effect of making every company think twice about using an EU country as a tax haven.
- iguy 6y agoSeems like there's a sovereignty issue here. If you negotiate a deal with the highest authority in Ireland, and they sign off on it, are you done? Why do you have to care what other deals they have made with other parties? Or is nothing Ireland does binding, until someone else with real power has counter-signed it?
- 6AA4FD 6y agoAll international agreements represent a sacrifice the "highest authority" makes, setting their reputation and future ability to make agreements as collateral. The "highest authority" further diluted its own authority by making a corporate deal that went against previously made agreements with its actual peers (states), damaging the collateral it already put up. Whatever ideas you have about the state needing to have the highest authority in the land, if we follow that through by not holding them accountable for agreements made, then that actually substantially dilutes the power the state can have.
- josefx 6y ago> Seems like there's a sovereignty issue here. Ireland signed on to the EU and several trade agreements before that. Until it quits these it is subject to their rules. > If you negotiate a deal with the highest authority in Ireland, and they sign off on it, are you done? Any contract you sign in any country can be invalidated by a court.
- iguy 6y ago> Ireland signed ... trade agreements ... is subject to their rules Sure. If your employment contract prevents you from taking other work, you may be fired if you break this. You may also have signed up to binding arbitration by some weird court. But normally the 3rd party (your weekend employer, who did not sign) cannot be penalized. That's what points out how much sovereignty has been given up by Ireland. It has signed up something much more than a trade deal. A foreign court can not just strike down laws it passes, but re-write them retrospectively a decade after the fact.
- 6y ago
- throw0101a 6y ago> Shouldn't then Ireland pay it (or act as if it was paid, and paid whatever it would have paid from it to the EU budget). The EU is not getting paid anything. The EU said that Apple should have paid Ireland more. It's like the EU saying to Germany "we thing that you are giving an unfair tax advantage to BMW compared to Renault: you need to collect more taxes from them".
- ogre_codes 6y ago> The EU argument was that Ireland's "previous established policies" were against EU treaty, and so the (alleged) special deal that IE gave Apple should be considered annulled since it was invalid from the day it was signed. Yet the EU sat on this for 12+ years allowing this agreement to continue. If they felt this was a concern, they should have addressed it in 2004... or any year between.
- groby_b 6y agoRemember when you were a kid, and your parents told you to clean your room last week, and they gave you a whole week to catch up? And then oddly, you were still on the hook even though they waited a whole week before grounding you? Same principle. Statutes of limitation exist for a reason.
- setr 6y agoAs I see it, apple didnt fail to clean its room. It was told not to clean it by the parent, who then got yelled at by the grandparent, and now a week later apple's being grounded by the parent. Ireland is the one that broke the treaty, not Apple. Apple played correctly within the rules & scope available to it, and is being retroactively told that those rules, in fact, did not exist, though certainly every other rule does exist, except for those that might not, depending on our decisions in twenty years.
- bodono 6y agoYour quotes are from the decision that was just overturned, ie, the commission was found to be wrong. The fact is those taxes were legal and not preferential state aid, as was just ruled.