6 ms·
Maybe I’m some sort of fascist, but I have zero problems with an officer using force to arrest someone who firebombed a police car, regardless of anyone was inj
by refurb 6y ago
Maybe I’m some sort of fascist, but I have zero problems with an officer using force to arrest someone who firebombed a police car, regardless of anyone was injured or she was an immediate threat after.
- Synaesthesia 6y agoI’ve seen so many examples of excessive and unwarranted force from the US police, by now hundreds of incidents.
- gremlinsinc 6y agoI know, I'm sure that old man in Buffalo was a real menace or the kid w/ the face mask who had it pulled down and was pepper sprayed.... and then there's the crowd control at the capital for Trump's photo shoot....that itself should be a war crime.
- refurb 6y agoI'm not excusing excessive force, I'm saying fire bombing in general is a felony and police should be able to arrest a suspect and use force if they don't comply (obviously reasonable force).
- pmiller2 6y agoThere is no evidence in the comment about this incident that indicates the suspect resisted in any way. This is what I meant about "missing context."
- pmiller2 6y agoYou may be some sort of fascist if you believe police disproportionately escalating violence is acceptable, but maybe not. At the very least, you're confused, IMO.
- refurb 6y agoDisproportionately escalating violence? I'm not saying the cop should get a few punches in, but detaining and arresting a suspect is not "escalating violence". Since you seem to a stickler for "proportional violence", would you be ok if the cop just located the suspects car and firebombed it? I mean, that's proportional, no?
- pmiller2 6y agoYou are clearly trolling and I'll not reply until you reformulate your question.
- ramshorns 6y agoViolence in retaliation is not an appropriate response to property damage.
- lostmsu 6y agoOh, but I think it is. Imagine sum of the pain of people, that they endured to make some property by having to craft it compressed in a few seconds when the result of their efforts gets destroyed.
- ancientworldnow 6y agoThings will never be worthy of more concern than lives. This is an absolutely warped viewpoint you have and trying to justify it after the fact by inventing workers who allegedly care a car spit off an assembly line was destroyed is delusional.
- lostmsu 6y agoViolence does not necessary lead to a loss of life. Not sure what you mean by my viewpoint being warped. As far as I am concerned, your viewpoint appears rather primitive to me. The workers, who built the car are real. The pain of doing any work is real, just not as dense a physical pain, but very long lasting - that's why you have to sum over it. If you thought I meant pain of these workers - that just proves your understanding is primitive. That description is just a way to approximate the total amount of pain, that needs to be endured to build a car. The subset of population, who will actually end up feeling its equivalence as a consequence does not matter for the point.
- happytoexplain 6y agoYou're saying that the pain of the people who crafted a police cruiser is alone worth committing violence against a person. Don't do that.
- lostmsu 6y agoYou are saying without an argument, that I should not express my opinion. Don't expect people to listen to you - you will be disappointed.
- happytoexplain 6y agoIf somebody incurs damage to government property without, as even you admit, any injury or immediate threat, and a government agent responds by using violence against that person, then yes, that is fascism. What perspective are you coming from that would define it any other way? You're practically admitting to using emotion to justify violence. Edit: Not to mention this is perhaps moot to the broader argument, as this behavior from the police only requires very few repeating instances to be extremely destructive to society, and cherry-picking cases where the victim arguably "deserved" it has no effect on the impact of the other cases.
- djsumdog 6y ago> If somebody incurs damage to government property There has been so much argument on the lines of "It's just property." I guess "They're just laws," as if they don't mean anything; as if laws were not the way we evolved socially to protect individuals from other individuals who wanted to cause harm. She set a car on fire! That is literally violence. It's literally destruction. Saying "oh, it's a thing and not a person" doesn't hold a candle stick to the fact that it is still literally violence! Words are literally not violence. Speech is literally not violence. Silence is literally not violence. Setting things on fire, that you don't own, destructively, is violence. I can't believe 2020 is the year in which we have no idea what terms like "violence" and "non-violence" have literally meant for decades if not centuries. Orwell had a term for this. It was called Double-Think.
- throwaway-92831 6y ago> She set a car on fire! That is literally violence. Not only that - there were four people inside the van and she aimed the explosive at the window in an obvious attempt to set fire to the passengers. Lots of mental gymnastics required to believe this wasn't attempted murder.
- pmiller2 6y agoWhy are you afraid to say that with your real account?