2 ms·
Multiple discussions about this on HN today, that's good. Maybe it will lead to the pendulum swinging back a bit. Interviewers need to do their due diligence.
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
Multiple discussions about this on HN today, that's good. Maybe it will lead to the pendulum swinging back a bit.
Interviewers need to do their due diligence. Coding tests can have their place when interviewing for certain kinds of positions, especially for new grads and entry level positions. In the end nothing can replace checking references and looking into a person's work experience.
There is no algorithms and data structure whiteboarding test that can differentiate between a junior and a senior developer. Being senior is a product of acquired wisdom, not just skill. And in fact senior devs can easily bomb out a whiteboarding test because we're further from university CS experience.
- glouwbug 6y agoYour last paragraph sums what why everyone on HN is so upset about the interview process. That is, the process is tailored for new grads, and what is being tested is not at all related to the job. 5 years of schooling, and 10 years of experience is not enough if you can't implement depth first search using double linked lists, hashes - and ultimately graph theory - within 45 mins. Heck, new grads can't even do so.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoWell, yes, if you looked at my comments you'd see I'm part of that "everybody" set. But to moderate it a bit; in my interview training at Google it was clear: the interviewee doesn't have to get the answer correct. The point is to see how they think. I mean, I think it's still insulting, but there is that.
- TrackerFF 6y agoYes, true regarding the very last part. My first "real" CS-related interview, which had technical questions, I had on the very same day that I had taken my final exam in our data structures and algorithms class. And because our DSA class was quite rigorous, I knew the material in and out. I absolutely aced those questions, but did poorly on the systems design questions because, well, I simply did not have much experience designing or building complete systems/software. Years later, it was the other way. I stumbled my way through the DSA questions, while acing the systems questions. But with that said, I think also the order of your performance matters. If you walk in, and absolutely bomb the first topics, I think there's going to be a bias against you. Maybe they'll think you're a moron, or something like that.