3 ms·
I find it interesting that academia often points out that skills interviews have a soft-skills bias, but rarely do I see them consider that this may be a featur
by kube-system 6y ago
I find it interesting that academia often points out that skills interviews have a soft-skills bias, but rarely do I see them consider that this may be a feature and not a bug.
> “Our study suggests that a lot of well-qualified job candidates are being eliminated because they’re not used to working on a whiteboard in front of an audience.”
This is a common daily task at any company I've ever written software at. People who can communicate their ideas effectively are better at their job.
- variaga 6y agoRight? At least pre-covid, I would say I spent at least an hour (sometimes many hours) every working day "explaining things on a whiteboard in front of an audience". It's a huge part of my job. (Post Covid, I do the same thing, but have to do it over chat) IMO: "Do you have a clear understanding of your area of expertise, and can you communicate that understanding on to others?" is a far more useful predictor of success than "Can you find the right answer to the kind of problem that can be solved on a whiteboard in 45 minutes, or in 5 minutes by searching for an answer on stackoverflow?" That said, I agree that generally interviews are terrible. But the (implicit) screening for soft skills isn't the terrible part.
- derivagral 6y agoI've had the opposite experience. In >10 years of software, I've never written code on a whiteboard outside of an interview. Systems layout, designs, code pathing, sure; but never real, compilable code. I agree with the last point, but I don't think either of us can tie our anecdotes to it.
- kube-system 6y agoThere is something to be said for the soft-skills evaluation being relative to the expectations of the job position, sure. I'm saying: I find it odd that I rarely see these types of studies discussing the merits of that nuance. Especially when the idea of differentiating between soft and hard skills is not something that would be foreign to the average interviewer. "Interviews are 100% for soft skills and technical evaluations are 100% for hard skills" seems to be a common assumption which I'd argue is false. Few tasks a developer does is purely a hard or a soft skill, there's always some overlap.