5 ms·
I would be highly interested in watching (or maybe participating) in a forum where the rule is to employ a certain kind of charity, where you must assume that e
by derefr 6y ago
I would be highly interested in watching (or maybe participating) in a forum where the rule is to employ a certain kind of charity, where you must assume that everyone you're speaking to is an AI who was just booted up, who was trained to know basically all the "is" facts about things (including politics), but who literally has no "ought" beliefs about anything (including politics.) Except maybe that there "ought" to be more paperclips :P
Anyone who breaks the kayfabe by expressing a human-like "ought" belief, would have their post flagged until dead (but isn't kicked out or punished otherwise; it's too easy to do accidentally, especially if you're new, and the point is to take such people and gradually get them used to having conversations that aren't fundamentally conflicts between opposing "ought" beliefs.)
- TigeriusKirk 6y agoThere was a time period when a principle of charity was promoted in this very forum. Perhaps it still is, but I haven't seen it mentioned in quite a while.
- lukifer 6y agoI do see references to the Principle of Charity occasionally, and I strongly support it. But to be meta-charitable to an anti-charity stance: doesn't a social norm of charity create an attack vector that can be exploited by dishonest actors? Alt-righters (the real ones) can use the Principle of Charity as cover, cherry-picking their talking points to just barely stay within the realm of acceptable "classical-liberal" discourse, while subtly nudging in the direction of ethnostates, distributed violence against The Other, etc. I'm very nearly a free speech absolutist, both politically and culturally. But we have "gut checks" for a reason, and I think it's okay to sometimes make a call that someone's BSing or disingenuously grandstanding, even if their surface arguments sound reasonable (Stefan Molyneux is my canonical example here). Obviously that has to be tempered and can easily go awry (per Eric Weinstein's model of "critical feeling"), but to eschew that instinct entirely robs us of a valuable "cheater detection" mechanism.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoYou are correct that charity can be exploited (both the "charitable interpretation" we strive for here, and giving actual resources to people in need). More generally, kindness can be exploited. Love can be exploited. Be charitable anyway. Be kind anyway. Love anyway. The alternative - not being charitable, not being kind, not loving - can ruin your life. Yes, you can be exploited. But give charity, kindness, and love, if not for the other person, then for yourself. Being the kind of person who won't be kind or love is miserable.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lukifer 6y agoI agree with this. One of the things I've always loved about Star Trek isn't just its radical utopian economics, and sentientist egalitarianism, but the specific parable of the Kobiyashi Maru: that it is preferable to knowingly enter a fatal trap that exploits our altruism, than to risk failing to help those who are truly suffering when it is in our power to do so. Still, I think it's better to make such choices intentionally, informed by both conscious deliberation and gut-check instincts. There are instances where one can "throw good money after bad", wasting altruistic resources to no end; or, where "tough love" is warranted, such as the case of enabling addicts and alcoholics, and the kindest act to take might be to withdraw. Reframing back to speech issues, the current standard I'd like to see in public squares, is the "beyond a shadow of a doubt" standard that is (ostensibly) applied in our legal system. It's easy to squint at something like "The Bell Curve" and see arguments for scientific racism, and under a "preponderance of evidence" standard, perhaps it would be found guilty; but we should find the prospect of discarding potentially true ideas as abhorrent as convicting a potentially innocent citizen. Nonetheless, in private life, we are free to draw whatever conclusions we please, where we consider that OJ Simpson probably committed murder, and Charles Murray might not be an entirely unbiased analyst. (Though perhaps the very crux of the matter is the blending between public and private realms of thought. What would a quasi-Bayesian Rule of Law look like in the court of public opinion and outrage mobs?)
- 6y ago
- cool_dude85 6y agoOften what you describe as "is facts", especially in areas of politics, are in question. I believe that global warming is occurring, but some others do not. I suspect that anytime you get into any discussion about the issue of global warming, you will find yourself getting very quickly into "ought beliefs". Also, it might also be very frustrating to not be able to express your "ought beliefs" about whether ethnicity X deserves to be put into concentration camps, and so on.
- whatshisface 6y agoGlobal warming isn't an "ought" belief, it's an "is" belief. "Animal species are being driven extinct" is an "is" belief. An example of an "ought" belief would be, "animal species should not be driven extinct." To further clarify, "the sunset is green" is also a (false) "is" belief.
- cool_dude85 6y agoYes, I agree. However, when I post "Global warming is occurring" and you post "global warming is not occurring", I suspect you will not get very far into exploring your disagreement before you come to a wall, below which are only "ought beliefs". And the same for most points of political disagreement. Very few political arguments online rest on questions of fact.
- whatshisface 6y ago>However, when I post "Global warming is occurring" and you post "global warming is not occurring", I suspect you will not get very far into exploring your disagreement before you come to a wall, below which are only "ought beliefs". Are you saying that people would change the subject because they prefer ought debates to is debates, or are you suggesting that trying to measure the temperature trend somehow depends on moral questions?
- cool_dude85 6y agoIt's just the kind of discussion that is very difficult to resolve without referring to "ought beliefs". B: "Global warming is not real." A: "It is real. Here are peer-reviewed articles, etc. etc." B: "That research is fraudulent. There's selection bias in choosing which papers to publish, etc." Now, A has a bit of a conundrum. He might like to say something like "Once there are 1000 published articles, studied this way and that way by so many different people, we can trust that it's actually happening", but this is an ought belief. I struggle to imagine how A can constructively respond with an "is statement."
- handoflixue 6y agoSlate Star Codex was absolutely amazing for that, but is currently down.