18 ms·
It's such an issue everywhere, I find it increasing on the internet. Even asking a question, and honest question where I want to hear someone's POV / answer ..
by duxup 6y ago
It's such an issue everywhere, I find it increasing on the internet.
Even asking a question, and honest question where I want to hear someone's POV / answer ... and folks assume you're a troll and assume you're the polar opposite of them.... and no amount of explaining otherwise changes people's minds.
Even outside questions I'll say "I agree, I think X too." and folks will still insist on arguing about how I believe Y. Bro I just said I agree...
It's a strange thing and I find myself constantly having to preface my statements in hopes people won't misunderstand.
- whatshisface 6y agoInternet bad-faith interpretation table: Speaks out against my belief: Mortal enemy. Questions my belief: Mortal enemy who my powerful comrades have cowed into not directly speaking out against my belief. Fails to show appropriate support for my belief at the appropriate times: Mortal enemy sleeper agent. Speaks in favor of my belief, but not in the way I would have: Exploitative opportunist who believes nothing but seeks to benefit from the glorious revolution. Speaks in favor of a belief that's almost identical to mine, but still, subtly distinguishable: The worse kind of heretic; a heretic within the faith.
- tanseydavid 6y agoPolitical puritanism does seem to be on-the-rise everywhere you look.
- foofoo4u 6y agoI am seeing this prefacing of arguments happening everywhere. For example, Sam Harris finds himself having to preface nearly argument he wants to make as a means to ward off misunderstanding and online retaliation. Unfortunately, no matter how much time he takes to preface, mobs online inevitably misunderstand his positions and call for his head. It's exhausting how no one can make any arguments anymore without going through the ritual of having to convince others they are not a bigot before proceeding with what they have to say.
- duxup 6y agoYeah I feel like the prefacing sometimes attracts a particular type of person that assumes some sort of bad faith simply because it is prefaced with something, and that obviously you're really arguing what you explicitly say you don't support.
- Balgair 6y agoI mean, at this point you just kinda have to accept that the medium is the message. Twitter (the medium) is about shouting and preening (the message). Honest discussions happen despite Twitter, not as a result. Instagram (the medium) is about jealousy and looking good (the message). Human to human connection happens despite Insta, not as a result. HN (the medium) is then about what (the message)?
- derefr 6y agoI would be highly interested in watching (or maybe participating) in a forum where the rule is to employ a certain kind of charity, where you must assume that everyone you're speaking to is an AI who was just booted up, who was trained to know basically all the "is" facts about things (including politics), but who literally has no "ought" beliefs about anything (including politics.) Except maybe that there "ought" to be more paperclips :P Anyone who breaks the kayfabe by expressing a human-like "ought" belief, would have their post flagged until dead (but isn't kicked out or punished otherwise; it's too easy to do accidentally, especially if you're new, and the point is to take such people and gradually get them used to having conversations that aren't fundamentally conflicts between opposing "ought" beliefs.)
- TigeriusKirk 6y agoThere was a time period when a principle of charity was promoted in this very forum. Perhaps it still is, but I haven't seen it mentioned in quite a while.
- lukifer 6y agoI do see references to the Principle of Charity occasionally, and I strongly support it. But to be meta-charitable to an anti-charity stance: doesn't a social norm of charity create an attack vector that can be exploited by dishonest actors? Alt-righters (the real ones) can use the Principle of Charity as cover, cherry-picking their talking points to just barely stay within the realm of acceptable "classical-liberal" discourse, while subtly nudging in the direction of ethnostates, distributed violence against The Other, etc. I'm very nearly a free speech absolutist, both politically and culturally. But we have "gut checks" for a reason, and I think it's okay to sometimes make a call that someone's BSing or disingenuously grandstanding, even if their surface arguments sound reasonable (Stefan Molyneux is my canonical example here). Obviously that has to be tempered and can easily go awry (per Eric Weinstein's model of "critical feeling"), but to eschew that instinct entirely robs us of a valuable "cheater detection" mechanism.
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago