2 ms·
It's a weird situation: So many people are a victim of being silenced now. As evidenced by how many people you hear about constantly telling you about it...
by duxup 6y ago
It's a weird situation:
So many people are a victim of being silenced now.
As evidenced by how many people you hear about constantly telling you about it...
- zachthewf 6y agoIndeed, the internet allows a public figure to simultaneously be a pariah to the mainstream and also have a platform where they reach millions.
- grimjack00 6y ago> and also have a platform where they reach millions. Until they're deplatformed.
- garraeth 6y agoAbsolutely not denying what you or pjc50 are saying (there are far too many who cry wolf, or benefit "inappropriately"), but I can imagine the case where some people may be in the honest situation where they feel they have been silenced because they cannot say what they would like to say. Individual 1: "I'm being silenced." Group: "What would you like to say that you think you're being silenced about?" Individual 1: "I cannot say for fear..."
- coldtea 6y agoThe comment sounds like a perfect example of siding with orthodox privilege... We did hear from victims of silencing back in the day just as well (and not just in the sense of state censorship, which many Americans have this bizarro notion that only it matters). From Lenny Bruce and Charlie Chaplin, to rap groups, from the Hayes code to book authors (including of masterpieces like "Junky"), from Hoover and McCarthy, to Jello Biafra, and from records getting thrown out of record store chains because they angered some group, all the way back to Galileo being silenced, black leaders (despite having large followings otherwise), etc. People do lose gigs, have talks cancelled, have book contracts dropped, shows demonetised, and so on because of mob reaction, or because of some angry special interest group, or because of some vocal bloggers, or whatever. Is the argument that they aren't completely stomped, so they should be thankful? Or that how someone be a victim of silencing and still be able to talk about their silencing and have it know?
- duxup 6y agoI feel like it goes both ways. I don't buy into the idea that 'any' friction is 'orthodox privilege' or anything else. In the meantime it is standard operating procedure / so easy for most humans to assume that any real friction is some sort of system or an act of bad faith.... and couldn't possibly be because of something else.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago>People do lose gigs, have talks cancelled, have book contracts dropped, shows demonetised, and so on because of mob reaction, or because of some angry special interest group, or because of some vocal bloggers, or whatever. Does it matter whether the reason for the "cancellation" came from a mob, or only what the reason actually is? If a group of crazy incoherent people get a Nazi cancelled by shouting "they're a Nazi!", and the person really is a Nazi, does it matter that they're a bit crazy and incoherent?
- coldtea 6y ago>If a group of crazy incoherent people get a Nazi cancelled by shouting "they're a Nazi!", and the person really is a Nazi, does it matter that they're a bit crazy and incoherent? On principle, for me, it does. For one, I don't want "groups of crazy incoherent people" dictating their terms. Second, I want all voices able to being heard, and adult audiences judging for themselves if they like to hear them. This includes access to book deals, speaking halls, conference spaces, etc. This includes Nazis or people in favor of the extinction of all mankind, fans of royal government against democracy, fans of Bieber, the KKK AND black panthers, and so on. As long as they don't act illegally/violently. Third, the tricky part is not agreeing with silencing a Nazi (which many will agree, some will disagree because they favour free exchange of ideas, whatever they are, but in any case it would be popular to do so). The tricky part is determining who is the "Nazi" (that is, the person to be silenced). And on that front, the tide turns very easily. Under Hoover a open leftist could lose their job. In the 50s a black rights supporter in the South could loose business deals, concert and writing gigs, get cancelled, etc. You think that this can happen from now on only on the "bad" side? Doesn't history taught you how fast the tides can turn? There was Obama just 4 years ago, and now it's Trump, for example...
- waterhouse 6y agoWell, one approach is to find people in the same reference class who have spoken and, for speaking, faced serious consequences. For example, they got formally punished (kicked out of a group, demoted, fired) for it, and a sympathetic journalist gave them a platform to tell their story about it later. This Twitter thread (oh lord, how did I end up citing Twitter multiple times in this conversation?), by the founder of an online magazine that seems to specialize in stories of this sort, has a long list of examples. https://twitter.com/clairlemon/status/1282215876553400321 https://twitter.com/clairlemon/status/1282215876553400321
- clairity 6y agohow about considering that the people telling you they're being silenced is a group of privileged folks unaccustomed to being pushed back upon publicly, with "cancel culture" as the reactive appellation for that push back?
- philwelch 6y agoThe fact that the set of people complaining about this includes people famous for openly discussing controversial ideas that they have received pushback and worse for in the past sort of refutes that. Do you really think this is the first time anyone has pushed back against Noam Chomsky? Salman Rushdie had a fatwa declared on his life over a book he wrote. I think these people are very well accustomed to being pushed back upon publicly.
- clairity 6y agono, most of the noise is from people who aren't as well-known or intellectually rigorous as chomsky and rushdie (whether you agree with them or not). these well-known rhetoriticians expect and likely welcome the pushback (obviously the counterarguments, not the threats on their lives). theirs is the exceptional context, not the exception that invalidates the general condition.
- philwelch 6y agoThe fact remains that both Chomsky and Rushdie signed the Harpers open letter and are hence two of the people publicly advocating on behalf of the people who have been silenced. You simply can’t honestly claim that this is an overreaction from people who aren’t used to pushback.
- clairity 6y agono, it's a rejection of your argument from authority, not a supporting claim of "overreaction from people who aren’t used to pushback". if you think there are other substantial coutnerclaims, please make them.
- panzagl 6y agoThis could almost be a Yogi Berra quote- "So many people are silenced nowadays, it's all you hear about"
- Orou 6y agoThis logic only follows if we assume censorship is applied to everyone, equally, all the time. Someone saying "hey, look there are a lot of instances of people being censored over there, we should be concerned about it because it could affect us" cannot be refuted on the basis that the speaker isn't being censored. It's like refuting someone saying that a bunch of people are ill on the basis that the speaker isn't ill themselves. Illness is something that occurs to individuals, not to society. Same with censorship. It isn't some absolute where people are totally censored or totally free to speak their mind. It's distributed unevenly across society. When understood as a distribution rather than something binary, it becomes obvious that instances of free speech about censorship doesn't disprove the existence of censorship, nor does it say anything about whether or not we are becoming a more censorious society.