6 ms·
Just to be sure we follow, could you name or describe those two orthodoxies?
by dgellow 6y ago
Just to be sure we follow, could you name or describe those two orthodoxies?
- sneak 6y agoI think the cultural shorthand for the -ists in question at the moment is “anti-PC” opposed with “woke” (in the non-pejorative sense; predictably enough it has also become a slur when used by those who oppose it). These roughly align with a lot of other social dichotomies (e.g. they map approximately to right/left, respectively) in the US, although not quite coterminously. There’s a lot of fuzzy leakage around the edges on a lot of issues that primarily map directly to this split.
- djsumdog 6y agoPeople want a political home. In countries without any type of per-capita representative voting system (where parties are split amount % of opinions like in MMP), they feel like they need to vote 'tactically.' At least in America, at one time people could say, "I don't believe in everything x wants, but I do agree with core policies a, b and c and so I'm voting for them." Today we are much more polarized and people desperate for a political home may start internalizing and adopting policies they may not totally agree with just so they don't feel left out in the middle. Cancel culture makes harder, if not impossible, to be in the middle. Are you against racism, but not for the specific BLM organization? You're opinion is not acceptable to the Democratic/politic-left. Is that a hill you're going to die on? If not, you move on and ignore it. This gets into some pretty dangerous territory because now you cannot say certain beliefs publicly without fear of ostracization from your political home. You may be able to keep that belief secret, or you may just start to believe the opposite. Viewpoints within each false-dichotomy lose their diversity, and both sides could bend, consciously and subconsciously, to a narrow, homogeneous world view.
- Spivak 6y agoWoke is a pejorative? Damn I really am in a bubble.
- antepodius 6y agoIt's widely considered comical.
- clairity 6y agothe mapped ideologies are dynamic (leaky), but the historically enduring dichotomy is simply power and its disciples vs. the disenfranchised. "anti-PC" is power retaliating against change, and "woke" is the disenfranchised calling for change. conservative and progressive also map to this same dichotomy.
- mumbisChungo 6y agoThe conflict between "anti-PC" and "woke" in its entirety is in service of power. A perpetual screaming match between poor and middle-class people, about topics that have little to no bearing on profits, is ideal for corporate elites.
- clairity 6y agoyes, there's some truth to that, but the latter group isn't aligned with power, even if the discussion serves the powerful's aims.
- panzagl 6y agoWhat do you mean? "Woke" is all about people with privilege trying to shield that privilege behind their correctthink as they attempt to disenfranchise the lower classes of their political rivals. "Woke" people do to Arkansas rednecks the same thing they accuse their opponents of doing to inner-city minorities.
- clairity 6y ago"woke" people are more diverse than you claim, and certainly less privileged on average. perhaps the "privileged woke" people you speak about over-exert their privilege, but that's a conquence of privilege, not wokeness.
- antepodius 6y agoWokeness and its methods are by their nature an amazing social shield and sword, so they attract the sort of people who want to cloak themselves in righteousness and tear into others.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoNot OP, but I will point out one example that should not be too controversial: "Science!". Note that label of science has been as politicized ( to the detriment of all of us ) as pretty much everything else. If you dare to question "Science!", you are, by default, backwood white trash racist or something along those lines, which happens to ignore that science encourages healthy debate and constantly questions underlying assumptions. This is literally how we get progress. Now, there is an argument to be made that words of a PhD carry more weight than FB educated person, but I think everyone here met a person with no formal education, who was still sharper than most people in the room ( and vice versa, an educated person arguing that black is white and getting himself killed crossing the next pedestrian crossing ). TLDR; "Science!" is one such orthodoxy.
- mumbisChungo 6y agoIn the orthodoxy discussed in the article, people are taking it for granted that their beliefs are true and working diligently to ridicule those who don't agree. In science, people hold many beliefs that have already been proven beyond a reasonable doubt and are working diligently to prove others.
- djsumdog 6y ago> beyond a reasonable doubt This might be true for things like the conventional laws of physics. But there are many things scientists do not agree or argue over. Quantum physics and string theory are two examples. The 1994 book The Bell Curve is another example from social sciences. And today, we have grave reproducibility crises in science. We have people trying to apply rules about the psychological and metaphysical worlds into the doctrine of hard science. In the current crisis, we have conflicting papers published almost every week, and there is a deep political climate that cannot be denied behind much of the current research. Even for thing that we can agree on work under experiment, like a certain class of drug, we can't explain WHY it works. We can say drug x will stop a heart attack 99% of the time and is generally considered safe in 99% of human beings, but often we're guess at the very specific interactions, based on what we see in labs, because we have no real introspection into all the complex things happening at the micro-level within the incredible complex cell systems inside of us. Maybe one day we'll be able to see what happens at that microlevel in human bodies, and that could lead us to discover the drug isn't working at all the way we thought it was. Science is iterative.
- Spooky23 6y agoAt a 50,000 foot level, you have: The "Progressive" camp, that has a few sub-genres that prioritize or disagree on different things. The "Conservative" camp, that is more consistent at a high level.
- Spivak 6y agoScott Alexander describes this view as "blue tribe" and "red tribe" where blue has a subgroup "grey" that broadly follows blue but disagrees with a good portion of blue's more extreme actions.
- tharne 6y agoThere's also a "grey" subgroup in the red tribe. For instance, a lot of Trump supporters will privately admit that he's a bad guy and an ineffective leader, but preferable to a liberal president. The problem is that the more extreme factions in both tribes wield the power and tend to punish what they see as heresy within their own camps before going after the other tribe. Most groups treat apostates worse than those who never believed in the first place.
- watwut 6y agoI find it hard to square Biden and Trump as supposedly same level of extreme. Or Clinton and Trump. They just are not the same level of extreme. Quite the opposite, the democratic party is significantly more choosing toward center figures. It also tend to choose less extreme tactics to get their way - there was no democratic goverment shutdown etc.
- antepodius 6y agoYes. One tribe is a cornered, bleeding, broken animal, one isn't.
- watwut 6y agoNeither is bleeding broken nor animal. That is nonsense. The cornered tribe would not be among two most powerful parties. Having president, majority of supreme court, senate or house suggests you are not cornered. And both parties are represented in those.
- tenaciousDaniel 6y agoNot entirely, because I'm speaking very broadly. You could probably name one of orthodoxies as the one colloquially known as social justice. It's the worldview that has gained significant traction over the course of the last five years. The other one is harder to define because it's essentially not the social justice worldview. In America, you tend to find the social justice worldview in urban and coastal areas, and you tend to find the latter in rural, interior locations. Obviously this generalization breaks down in many ways, so [insert all the caveats].
- malandrew 6y ago> one colloquially known as social justice My main beef with this is that even the philosophical father of social justice, John Rawls, would not recognize the means by which this movement is trying to achieve its ends as any form of justice and in any way aligned with his original position and veil of ignorance thought experiment. The movement as currently practiced is one grand perversion with all the hallmarks of other populist illiberal (but believe they are liberal) movements that resulted in indisputable injustice.
- tenaciousDaniel 6y agoYep, definitely. It's why it's colloquial. In my view, the usage of that term today carries the same descriptive weight as terms like "free market". It's more evocative than literal.
- antepodius 6y agoThe end is justice, so is justified the means. Sit down, shut up, your crown bequeathe.
- bob33212 6y agoGroup A would say they are "Sex and Gender Positive and Inclusive". Group A would also say people who disagree with Group A are "Transphobic" Group B would say that they "Support Free Speech". Group B would also say that people who disagree with Group B are Maoists