2 ms·
Some states with incompetent governance allow nonsense like that. A local retailer was telling people that they wouldn't enforce mask use once you entered the
by Spooky23 6y ago
Some states with incompetent governance allow nonsense like that.
A local retailer was telling people that they wouldn't enforce mask use once you entered the building. Someone called the health department, and they were shut down within 3 hours.
- kube-system 6y agoYes, but that is very different than the sign I posted above. Businesses generally do not have the authority nor capability to judge anyone's medical conditions.
- ceejayoz 6y agoBusinesses absolutely have the authority to say "no mask, no entry", just like they can set "no shoes, no shirt, no service" policies. The ADA requires reasonable accommodation, and has explicit exemptions to accommodations that pose a health threat to others. https://www.ada.gov/taman3.htm#III-3.8000 https://www.ada.gov/taman3.htm#III-3.8000 > III-3.8000 Direct threat. A public accommodation may exclude an individual with a disability from participation in an activity, if that individual's participation would result in a direct threat to the health or safety of others.
- kube-system 6y agoIt is not clear that legally meets the definition of "direct threat". > On May 26, 2020, a woman with an alleged respiratory disability filed suit under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) against a supermarket chain in Pennsylvania after she was denied entry because she could not wear a face mask. > [...] Does the risk of spreading the coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) qualify as a “direct threat”? Cases like this may start to provide an answer to that question. https://ogletree.com/insights/no-mask-no-service-supermarket-sued-for-disability-discrimination-over-strict-face-covering-policy/ https://ogletree.com/insights/no-mask-no-service-supermarket... The fact that lawyers can't quite agree on this, should be more than enough to evidence to show that it will also not be clear to the laypeople who are responsible for setting, following, and enforcing those policies within stores. I am sure my local news and anecdotal experiences are also not unique in showing that compliance has been spotty. This is the US; being uncooperative is basically our national past-time. Most people will avoid confrontation, and when confrontation does happen, it'll be rare that police get involved unless they escalate to violence.
- ceejayoz 6y agoIf a court doesn't find "refuses to wear a mask during a global pandemic" to be a direct threat to the health of others, I'll eat my hat. Offering something like curbside pickup is, under the ADA, a "reasonable accommodation". People who genuinely can't wear a mask should request it.
- kube-system 6y ago> If a court doesn't find "refuses to wear a mask during a global pandemic" to be a direct threat to the health of others, I'll eat my hat. For a person not diagnosed with COVID-19 who is simply occupying a space and not in direct contact with another person -- I'd think that could be reasonably described as "indirect threat" > Offering something like curbside pickup is, under the ADA, a "reasonable accommodation". People who genuinely can't wear a mask should request it. That is a good solution to the issue and I personally wish more businesses would take this route to solve the problem, but unfortunately it is not happening. If I call up my local gas station and tell them I want a Snickers bar, have a medical condition and can't wear a mask, the $8/hr employee on the other end is either going to argue with me or tell me to come in anyway. They're not going to contemplate the implications of the ADA and determine that curbside pickup is the best legal solution to the issue. These are really the kinds of national conversations that should be facilitated from the top, but unfortunately that is not the perspective that our current leadership has.
- Spooky23 6y agoThe gas station cashier doesn't make a decision, they follow a policy. No sane business assumes that cashiers think. I'm an escalation point for a not for profit that I serve on the board of. Our policy is that to be in a public space on our property, you must be masked. If you refuse to comply, the frontline worker's protocol is to ask you to leave the property. If you refuse to leave, you are trespassing, and the employee or supervisor calls the police. Supervisors are empowered to make some limited accommodations, but masks must be worn in public spaces. If the employee ignores the policy, they are given one warning, then treated as insubordinate, usually terminated. State regulations are very clear in our state, so if someone wants to sue, go for it. 95% percent of "health concerns" using masks are BS, and protecting our people is more important that worrying about an ADA lawsuit. Usually the people with a problem that leads to a police call flip out and act like an ass on camera, so have fun with the judge.
- Spooky23 6y agoThey don't need to -- ADA requires accommodation, not the wild west. In my state, emergency order requires masks in public spaces, and exempts retailers/others from any state liability. The Feds have the power to do the same.