3 ms·
I wonder if you can talk a little about how you determine whether or not astroturfing is going on. How can you be sure that a given post with a political or na
by CamperBob2 6y ago
I wonder if you can talk a little about how you determine whether or not astroturfing is going on. How can you be sure that a given post with a political or nationalist slant is made in good faith? You seem pretty confident that it's not a widespread problem, which is great, but it would be good if the rest of us could share at least some of that confidence.
Is it really enough to look at the account history and observe that the same user has participated in other unrelated threads? Or are there more subtle cues that you go by?
- dang 6y agoWe can't know for sure. Past account histories count for a lot—if people would simply look at them, I think most accusations of this sort would vaporize. It's not plausible that $secret-enemy planted $hn-user in 2013 to comment about syntactic whitespace and Google Fiber or whatever, so they'd be more credible seven years later when promoting $political-agenda. Beyond that, we look at relationships between accounts, patterns of site access...I'm not sure what else to tell you. The private data confirms what the public data already shows. There are exceptions, but they don't determine the discourse on the site. What determines that is people simply having different views. Mostly I just wish people would realize that the spectrum of genuine disagreement is much broader than it seems like it should be, would be, or could be. The world is just a bigger place than we feel like it is.