4 ms·
It sounds like you're making a semantic argument. To you "progressives" by definition adhere to a liberal ethos (perhaps even that any who adhere to a certain l
by throwaway894345 6y ago
It sounds like you're making a semantic argument. To you "progressives" by definition adhere to a liberal ethos (perhaps even that any who adhere to a certain liberal ethos are also 'progressives'), ergo they can't be the ones doing the (inherently illiberal) cancelling. Others are observing that the group that identifies as (and is commonly known as) 'progressives' seem to be practicing or defending cancellation.
As is often the case with semantic arguments, it's probably not very useful to debate terms, and you're probably just better off to say "cancelling is abhorrent and anyone who does it deserves criticism and condemnation irrespective of their 'tribe'" and move on.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoNo, that's a complete misstatement of what I said. I acknowledge in that comment that there are people who call themselves "progressives" whose behavior would be considered by many to not be aligned with progressive ideology. I acknowledge in another comment below that there are people who call themselves "conservatives" whose behaviour and/or beliefs do not align with the general understanding of conservative political ideology. Neither of these facts about the world changes the difference(s) in the nature of progressive and conservative political ideologies. Among those differences is the general trend for progressivism to be inclusive and tolerant of difference, and for conservatism to be exclusionary and less tolerant of difference. And who knows, conservatives might be right - perhaps stable societies do need a conservative stance (unclear). That doesn't mean that the two philosophies are the same, which in turns makes the behavior of people who attach themselves to those philosophies likely to skew in different directions.
- throwaway894345 6y agoSo are you making the “small vocal minority” argument? “Most progressives are principled liberals who condemn cancellation but we never hear from them”? And why are you focusing so much on doctrine as though progressive doctrine and not progressive behavior is on trial. I take very little consolation from the idea that progressive doctrine condemns cancellation or that in theory progressives ought to be tolerant and conservatives intolerant.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoWhat does "progressive behavior" mean? What does "conservative behavior" mean? The sort of thing typically being discussed here (in relation to so-called "cancel culture") typically involve the action of a few thousand (or less) people working almost entirely online or within the context of a small social context (for example a college). For me, what matters are policies enacted that have the power to affect thousands or millions of people. Whether or not I approve of or even believe in "cancel culture", it's a marginal affair whether it's affecting conservatives or progressives. Progressive policy vs. conservative policy? There's no contest, no comparison between the two that does not differentiate heavily between them on the basis of inclusivity, tolerance, egalitarianism and so forth. As Atrios notes (a lot; Eschaton) "oh noes, those crazy powerful college kids have gotten another conservative speaker to go away while meanwhile there's been another tax cut, another step toward voting disenfranchisement, another shift towards even greater wealth/income inequality etc. etc". In short, given the scale of the impact actual policy, I'm not sure how much I care whether there actually is a "cancel culture" or not.
- throwaway894345 6y agoBy “progressive behavior” I meant “how progressives have been behaving”. Cancelling and defending cancellation. As far as I’m aware, there is no significant number of progressives who have condemned this behavior, although I could be mistaken or perhaps you would define “progressives” differently such that it largely excludes those who cancel and approve of cancellation (I have no interest in these semantic debates). You may not be interested in cancel culture, but I am—it chills speech, hinders the very debate we need to move forward on many issues, and sets a precedent that conservatives could use if they decided to be so illiberal.
- PunchTornado 6y agoI think you should care because 'cancel culture' is discussed everywhere now and has a deep emotional weight that can change people's opinion and how they vote. I don't know how many people are still in the center and undecided politically with this tribalism, but cancel culture could and is used politically now (among others, by Trump).