5 ms·
In search of 2.11BSD, as originally released
- irl_zebra 6y agoI love these great, though utterly useless, projects people do for the love of things and for no other reason than it’s something interesting to them. I will be following along.
- maxmcd 6y agoHistory is not useless
- retrac 6y agoFar from useless. Often educational.
- bsdimp 6y agoIt's my COVID-19 insomnia project...
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoWhat year/month was this version released? It’s not in the article.
- jmartinpetersen 6y agoMarch 1991, it seems. https://www.krsaborio.net/bsd/research/1991/0314.htm https://www.krsaborio.net/bsd/research/1991/0314.htm
- MarxOk 6y agoIt's surprising how often "utterly useless" project turn into huge companies. I for one will keep pursuing them :D
- pmarin 6y agoI always find weird to read this kind of comment in a forum with "hacker" in the title.
- nix23 6y agoYes this!! Its normal to read comments like that in linkedIn but not on HN...same as why use 9front/*BSD/Haiku/Inferno? Just take a normal Linux Distribution.
- alekq 6y ago+1 It is great encouragement that time investment is never lost if it is something you love and enjoy, even when no one else has benefit of it.
- breput 6y ago2.11BSD is still getting patches[1] - mostly due to renewed interest from the PiDP-11 project[2]. Recent changes[3] include the addition of the 'top' utility. Reverting to patch level zero is an interesting exercise but there are still plenty of people who are interested in maintaining and updating the operating system. Edit: And I understand the pain - the "patches" are a eclectic mix of straight diff output, shell archives, uuencoded compressed tar files, and all sorts of manual steps. But the patch "readme" information is unusually verbose and the update instructions are well written and informative. [1] https://www.tuhs.org/Archive/Distributions/UCB/2.11BSD/Patches/ https://www.tuhs.org/Archive/Distributions/UCB/2.11BSD/Patch... [2] https://obsolescence.wixsite.com/obsolescence/pidp-11 https://obsolescence.wixsite.com/obsolescence/pidp-11 [3] https://github.com/chasecovello/211bsd-pidp11 https://github.com/chasecovello/211bsd-pidp11
- microcolonel 6y agoTurn 'em into git commits. I've done this with a lot of things which only have changelogs and tarballs, it is convenient.
- breput 6y agoTo do that, you'd really need the entire 2.11BSD distribution in source control. So the real problem would be that you'd need to start with...patch...level...zero. :whoa: Seriously, that would be a beautiful thing from a historic standpoint. But there is no git client for 2.11BSD, so you'd also end up having to build a git->something (probably shell archive and b64 compressed tar) that could allow the 2.11BSD system to update itself (and we're talking a 16/22 bit system here). There are also changes that require kernel recompiles and/or reboots so it turns out to be an extremely difficult problem. Which is why there are these human readable patches.
- progman32 6y ago> To do that, you'd really need the entire 2.11BSD distribution in source control. So the real problem would be that you'd need to start with...patch...level...zero. :whoa: I might be misunderstanding, but I don't think this is true. As long as there's a complete snapshot to start from anywhere in the revision history, it's possible to apply each patch in reverse (as far back as possible), even if it doesn't get all the way to patch level 0. Then later, if earlier patches are found, these can be applied in reverse and the branch rebased.
- progman32 6y agoReminds me of this recent video on recovering Luminary 69, Apollo 10's lunar module code (the only known copy of which is somewhere in solar orbit) by careful reconstruction of the development process: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-JTa1RQxU04 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-JTa1RQxU04 This exploitation of side-channels is something to pay attention to. Data is rarely fully lost!
- taejo 6y agoIn that case someone found a listing of the checksums of the code that launched in the archives (!), that could be used to verify the reconstruction. I wonder if there's anything like that for 2.11BSD
- chungy 6y agoThis reminds me of a thing in the Doom community to restore a "lost" release of DOSDOOM: https://github.com/Doom-Utils/historic-ports/commit/ce8bbd699f29452edf7d02b912b49146a80144ed https://github.com/Doom-Utils/historic-ports/commit/ce8bbd69...
- ChuckMcM 6y agoFor some reason I thought this was on the PUPS disc?
- bsdimp 6y agoNo. 2.11BSDpl195 is the earliest one available. It's what was on the old PUPS disk... PUPS became TUHS (http://www.tuhs.org http://www.tuhs.org) and this is the oldest one there and none of the old timers that ran 2BSD in PDP11 have the original tapes.
- DNied 6y agoIt could be an interesting website, but I really don't feel like scrolling horizontally all the time to read the text.
- fireattack 6y ago>scrolling horizontally What do you mean? The text renders fine here on both desktop and mobile (no need to scroll horizontally).