2 ms·
> The point was at least some of request was invalid by the law in Belgium. From what little information was provided in the article, it sounded like Google ma
by karaterobot 6y ago
> The point was at least some of request was invalid by the law in Belgium.
From what little information was provided in the article, it sounded like Google maintained that these search results were exempt from the law, because they were political in nature, so they stood their ground.
However the DPA determined that these results were NOT exempt, due to the particular facts of the case (the results were "irrelevant and outdated"). So, keeping them up did not serve the public good (which, I resume, is the justification for these exemptions).
To me, it sounds like Google chose the wrong test case to stand their ground on. I appreciate them taking a stand on keeping information available if it is important.
But, crucially, Google claiming the request was invalid does not make it invalid; that's for the DPA to decide.
- unishark 6y ago> But, crucially, Google claiming the request was invalid does not make it invalid; that's for the DPA to decide. Except apparently the DPA requires google to decide. And hits them with a hefty fine if they pick the wrong answer. I believe this is the point being made in the thread. Google suffers all the risk.