3 ms·
hackers are makers, and it often spills over into other kinds of production Yes, definitely. I think hackers may be more like architects than painters, for exa
by pg 18y ago
hackers are makers, and it often spills over into other kinds of production
Yes, definitely. I think hackers may be more like architects than painters, for example. The reason I wrote about the connection between hacking and painting is that I understand painting fairly well. I haven't studied architecture.
The core of this Dabblers & Blowhards thing is a strawman argument. He claims I say the connection between hacking and painting is much stronger than I do, then "proves" it isn't. When in fact all I say is:
of all the different types of people I've known,
hackers and painters are among the most alike.
(http://paulgraham.com/hp.html http://paulgraham.com/hp.html)
- startingup 18y agoWell, in that case, the title of the book "Hackers and Painters", overstates the connection. As a programmer who has had some success and money (and not a painter, not a musician, in fact, not well-endowed in any of the arts, but with a fairly decent math background), I have to say that I found the connection tenuous too. Not to say I don't agree with PG on most things - I actually do. If I were to write a book I would say "Hackers & Thinkers" because that's what I do with my time - think about things.
- cglee 18y agoI don't see how linking hacking and thinking brings any new insight. It's pretty obvious the two are connected. Hacking and painting is a more interesting cross-pollination. The title "Hackers and Painters", in my opinion, doesn't overstate anything - it's an appropriate title, out of many, for the essay.
- startingup 18y agoI said "Hackers and Thinkers" just to illustrate the point that we tend to overemphasize our own particular areas of interest. Hacking and thinking don't have to go together - as an example, PG is a thinker who writes essays, but there exist many great hackers who don't spend much time thinking about general stuff. They tend to be fairly narrowly focused.
- IsaacSchlueter 18y agoI think hackers may be more like architects than painters, for example. I've always felt that the character of Howard Roark captures the quintessential hacker quite well. Not being an architect, I can't comment on how well he represents architects, or how common that overlap might be :) At least as I interpreted it, your essay doesn't argue for the connection between the activities of hacking and painting as much as between the people who do these things. Devotion to a craft that brings artistic satisfaction attracts a certain sort of person.
- xlnt 18y agoAs much as I admire Howard Roark, could you explain more clearly how we hackers can take credit for him?
- IsaacSchlueter 18y agoHahaha, I'm not sure "we hackers" can take credit for him -- he's Ayn Rand's creation, after all, and she didn't even use a typewriter. Although, on the subject of "Hackers and Blank", her essays on writing always very much echoed my feelings about programming. I collected some illustrative quotes from the book in this blog post: http://foohack.com/?p=32 http://foohack.com/?p=32
- xlnt 18y agoI think you wanted to link http://foohack.com/2007/10/required-reading-for-web-developers-the-fountainhead-by-ayn-rand/ http://foohack.com/2007/10/required-reading-for-web-develope...
- IsaacSchlueter 18y agoSay, well that's odd. My short URLs don't work unless you're signed in. I suspect WP-Supercache is to blame. Thanks for fixing the link. This works: http://foohack.com/index.php?p=32 http://foohack.com/index.php?p=32
- tptacek 18y agoHe claims you say the connection between hacking and painting is strong, in an essay titled "Hackers and Painters", in which you say, "of all the different types of people I've known, hackers and painters are among the most alike". I think you're begging the question. Moreover, you yourself are constructing a straw man. His point isn't simply that your comparison is broken, but that it's hopelessly filtered through your own experience. He knows you see similar connections with architects. He's saying, the only reason you picked "painters" was that your art education taught you to admire painters and their lifestyle. The word "fatuous", repeated in his essay, is the core of his argument: that your insight about the relation between Hackers and Painters is superficial, and where it applies at all, it's built on knowledge of painting that is itself superficial. I neither agree nor disagree, but it's graceless to dismiss him like that. I'd be flattered to have someone refute me as carefully as he did you.
- pg 18y agothe core of his argument: that your insight about the relation between Hackers and Painters is superficial, and where it applies at all, it's built on knowledge of painting that is itself superficial. Can you give an example where you feel he has successfully refuted something specific I said about painting?
- tptacek 18y agoSure. I've taken his thesis and applied it, substituting "pastry chef" for "painter" into the text of each of the topic sentences in the lead graf of each section of your essay. The essay continues to work. Your critic's point seems valid. You learn to bake mostly by doing it. Ditto for hacking. Because pastry chefs leave a trail of work behind them, you can watch them learn by doing. For a pastry chef, a cookbook is a reference library of techniques. Another example we can take from pastry is the way that dishes are created by gradual refinement. New dishes usually begin with a sketch. In hacking, like pastry, work comes in cycles. Sometimes you get excited about some new project and you want to work sixteen hours a day on it. Other times nothing seems interesting. A lot of the great cooking of the past is the work of multiple hands, though there may only be one name on the wall of the restaurant. Like pastry, most software is intended for a human audience.
- JabavuAdams 18y agoInteresting. I was telling one of the artists that I work with that a programmer is like a cross between an architect and a lawyer. We build [abstract, conceptual] structures, but need to assign precise meanings to concepts. It's not as catchy, and it does not fully capture the engineering aspect, but I was pleased with it at the time.