4 ms·
> This is the same problem with DMCA, where every request gets rubberstamped, because if you don't comply with the request and it later turns out to be valid, y
by tzs 6y ago
> This is the same problem with DMCA, where every request gets rubberstamped, because if you don't comply with the request and it later turns out to be valid, you lose your safe harbor status and can be held liable for the infringement.
You've left out the other half of the DMCA. Yes, the take down request gets rubber stamped and your content goes down.
But if you file a counter-notice with the provider saying the the content was not violating copyright, that too is rubber stamped and the provider is required to put the content back up unless the take down requestor shows that they have actually filed a copyright infringement suit against you.
To get the content taken down and have it stay down the requestor has to go through the judicial system.
- ianlevesque 6y agoUnfortunately it’s all pretty theoretical now that YouTube and others use a content ID system that goes well beyond the legal requirements thanks to all the lawsuits years ago.